Faraday to Schœnbein.
You know how I value your letters and may conclude that the last was very pleasant to me…
Faraday to Schœnbein.
Royal Institution 30. July 1838.
My dear Sir
You know how I value your letters and may conclude that the last was very pleasant to me; though there is always a feeling of deep regret that the treasures which accompany your communications being in the German language are sealed up to me. I was out of town when your letter arrived and have not had the fortune to see Dr. Brabant but I hope he enjoyed himself in England.
[p. 51]Your paper on the possible condition of Iron in its peculiar state I have taken to Mr. Taylor (as well as the parcel). Your theory is just now in that state as respects the facts of the case that one may very well be allowed the be not too sure either for or against it but you can hardly think I should consider any opinion of yours as unworthy of publication. I have far too much respect for the judgment you have shown in these very delicate and difficult enquiries.
You mention Fechner’s objections to my theory and I am exceedingly anxious to see and consider them but do not know whether they are all acceptable to me or not. Would you mind referring me in your next to Poggendorff or other Journals in which they are; mentioning the pages in which the path of the objection or the positive experiments are and then I will have them translated. I am rather in hopes that the paper you say you have sent to Mr. Taylor will in fact refer to and perhaps state them. I am very anxious to know of all important objections but I do not mind about slight ones. Many have been made to me which been left to themselves have disappeared in a few months from the minds of the objecters themselves; but good and valid objections are of great importance and often I think prove the key to new discoveries.
Dr. Poggendorff1 who was here lately told me of Fechners objections but when he learnt from me that I by no means go the length of De la Rive and that I admit many other modes of electrical excitement besides chemical action, I thought he seemed to think that Fechners objections were rather against De la Rive than me. Perhaps what I am saying has not reference to Fechners objections but what I believe is that the Electricity which characterises the Voltaic pile (binding [?] the phenomenon
[p. 52]to that instrument) is of chemical origin; is another form of chemical affinity and I think the notes to paragraphs 856. 921. 928 indicate that to be my meaning, besides the general tenor of the papers and descriptions contained in it.
I have been writing on Induction and have three new papers (series 11. 12. und 13),1 and shall soon have a fourth for you. I am rather uncertain whether you receive those I send you by our Royal Society. If you do not let me know: and if you know any channel which [is] fitter for the purpose and will tell me I will send them to you by it at once. —
I am very heavy in experiment just now and have some results with crystals which I think you will approve of. — I must now conclude in haste but not the less
Sincerely Yours
M. Faraday.
❦
Notes
- 1Johann Christian Poggendorff Ph. D. M. D. formerly an apothecary, was born in 1796 at Hamburg He was professor at the University and member of the Academy of Science at Berlin where he died in 1877. He edited 160 volumes of the Annalen which bear his name.
- 1Phil. Trans. 1838. p. 1 and 79. p. 83 and p. 125.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.


