Faraday to Schœnbein.
I was about to write to you the other day and was stopped by a reason…
Faraday to Schœnbein.
Royal Institution 18 Feby 1843
My dear friend
I was about to write to you the other day and was stopped by a reason, which you will perhaps think very odd and insufficient unless indeed you bring a little German subtlety of thought to bear upon it. I had put the book, which to me is a sealed book, into the hands of Grove and just as I was about writing he sent me two pages of writing, a translation of part which his wife has made: — it was the authors opinion of myself1 and was a character so beautiful and of which I felt myself so utterly unworthy, even if it had come from my loving wifes thought, that I was quelled under it and constrained to be pen-dumb. I do not doubt your sincerity in the least, but knowing a little of my own heart I cannot help thinking of the hypocrisy, which must have contributed to such an impression. You see I have my fancies as well as you; you will perhaps count amongst them this, that I think but poorly of human nature, but certainly in my own heart I find nothing to raise my estimate of it; at the same time, I must allow that I find a great deal which does do so amongst my friends. The upshot is, that though I cannot appropriate your good opinion, I thank you most earnestly for it and will try to become in some degree what you describe. I wish your book was translated here. I heard very highly of it from Kohl the Russian traveller who spoke of its character also in Germany.2
[p. 102]I have now your paper in the “Archives” and purpose taking it on Monday to Brighton to read, but I must not delay my letter for that, for I do not know what else may come over me to stop my writing — a small thing is to me a great obstacle at times and I fear to trust the future. I think I saw in some paper of Herschels1 lately a notion that the peculiar Iron was Iron in another state and yet iron2 — like the existence of two states of carbon or sulphur or other bodies that show at times and under certain circumstances these or such differences.
I am surprised at what you say of the British Association not acknowledging your paper. If I can remember I will take the first opportunity of asking the reason.
Moser’s papers3 I am now reading in the translation in Taylors Scientific Memoirs.4 So many persons were putting forth accounts of effects, that I ventured in a short note in the Literary Gazette to suggest, that all such experiments and statements should now be accompanied by some fundamental experiments made in Vacuo and others made with rock salt. Many of the effects I have heard described, I have no doubt are due to mere vapours. Such effects may be separated from those of radiation in a certain degree by making them in vacuo —
[p. 103]and also again by interposing rock salt — for there seems no reason to doubt that Moser’s experiments of true radiation would succeed, though a thin plate of rock salt were interposed.1
During the last 8 or 9 months I have worked a little on the Electricity of high pressure steam and sent a paper to the Royal Society2; perhaps they may print it and then I shall again have the pleasure of sending you a paper of mine. The electricity is not due to evaporation — nor to the steam itself — but solely (I believe) to the friction of the particles of water which the steam carries with it and I can make it Positive or Negative on either side at pleasure. Water standing above .....3 and all other bodies yet tried on, become Positive when rubbed against other bodies.
Peltier’s4 expts and views of the relation of the earth and space rather startle me. What do you think? I do not think I shall be able to assent to the properties which he gives to space.
You really hold out very tempting pictures of the Black forest etc. etc. etc. but none more tempting than the hearty pleasure of seeing you and Mrs. Schœnbein and the children — to all remember us very kindly. But this year will not see us out of Britain, and Scotland will be the farthest place we shall go to. There, family friends have looked for years for us
[p. 104]and I doubt whether even they will see us this year after all. Again with heartiest feelings of remembrances to you and Mrs. Schœnbein from us both.
I am My dear friend
Gratefully Yours
M. Faraday.
❦
Notes
- 1The passage here referred to by Faraday is in Schœnbeins Reisetagebuch (Bâle, 1842) p. 277. “It is my conviction” he says “that, so far as scientific merit is concerned, Faradays discoveries surpass those of Davy, his teacher; though we may call the work of the latter more brillant, more striking. However, even if we merely owed to Faraday the discovery of magneto-electricity, that alone would suffice to entitle him to immortal fame.”
- 2Johann Georg Kohl was born in 1808 at Bremen, lived for many years in Russia, and died in 1878 at Bremen.
- 1Phil. Mag. S. 3. vol. 14. 1839. p. 32. which deals with meteoric iron from South Africa. In dissolving a specimen of it in nitric acid for the purpose of analysis, Herschel found that towards the end of the solution the iron assumed the peculiar state of resistance to the action of the acid, observed by Schœnbein.
- 2A similar suggestion was made by Berzelius in Stockholm Akad. Handl. 1843. p. 1. Schœnbeins reply to this is contained in a letter to Berzelius dated Feb. 23. 1844 in which he says: “The only remarkable thing about it is, that the allotropy should be confined to the surface, and not extend in any degree to the interior of the iron; for the current which determines the passivity of the iron goes through every part of the iron, which serves as positive electrode.” Kahlbaum, Briefwechsel. p. 42.
- 3vide note 4. p. 98.
- 4Scientific Memoirs (Taylor) Prt. 3. 1843. p. 422. The treatises giving an account of his discoveries are: On the action of light on bodies; On invisible light; and On the power which light possesses of becoming latent.
- 1Robert Hunt F. R. S. (of the Mining School, at Chelsea) comes to the conclusion that the effect in question is dependent on a chemico-mechanical action, or what Berzelius has called catalytic action. Prater on the other hand, replying to Hunt in the Athenaeum (1843, p. 598) reminds him, that Mosers images cannot be taken at any distance from the plate when polishing, boiling or screens are used. The effect in question seems therefore, according to Prater, to be mere chemical action, produced by direct contact.
- 2An abstract of it is to be found. Phil. Mag. S. 3 vol. 22. 1843. p. 570. vide also 18th ser. Researches on Electricity. Phil. Trans. 1843. p. 17.
- 3The word after above is, in the original, illegible.
- 4Jean Charles Athanase Peltier was born at Ham in 1785. He was a watchmaker and dealer in clocks till 1815, after which he lived on his own means in Paris, where he died in 1845.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.



