Schœnbein to Faraday.

SchœnbeinFaraday

I trust you received in due time the letter I sent you through Dr. Whewell some months…

17 · X · 1852BâlePrinted pp. 205–207

Schœnbein to Faraday.

My dear Faraday

I trust you received in due time the letter I sent you through Dr. Whewell some months ago. Now I avail myself of a friend going to London, to forward to you a paper of mine, which I hope will not remain a sealed book to you. If you should feel curious to decipher that whimsical letter I once wrote you about oxigen, get the memoir translated by some friend of your's and you will perhaps be interested in the matter, as it regards some of your most important discoveries.

Entertaining the notion that in many, if not in all cases, the color exhibited by oxycompounds is due to the oxigen contained in them, or to express myself more distinctly, to a peculiar chemical condition of that body, I have continued my researches on the subject and obtained a number of results which I do not hesitate to call highly curious and striking. Far be it from me to think, on that account, my hypothesis correct and proved; but the fact is that I owe the discovery of a number of remarkable phenomena solely and exclusively to the conjecture mentioned. I am nearly sure that you will be pleased to repeat the experiments, for either by mere physical means or by chemical ones you may make and unmake or change the color of a certain substance without altering the chemical constitution of those matters. To my opinion, that wonder is performed by changing the chemical condition of the oxigen of the oxycompound.

I cannot help thinking that the colors of substances, which up to this present moment have been very slightly treated (in a chemical point of view) will one day become highly important to chemical science and be rendered the means to discover the most delicate and interesting changes taking place in the chemical condition of bodies. In more than one respect the

[p. 206]

color of bodies may be considered the most obvious “signatura rerum”, as the revealer of the most wonderful actions going on in the innermost recesses of substances, as the indicator of the most elementary functions of what we call ponderable matter. But alas! Whilst we are pleased with and wonder at that rich field of chromatic phenomena, which continually strike our eye, we know as yet little or nothing of the connexion which certainly exists between the chemical nature of bodies and the influence it exerts upon light. We must try to dissipate that thick darkness which still hangs about and obscures the most luminous phenomena. Clearing up but the smallest part of that vastly important subject would be of more scientific value, I think, than discovering thousand and thousand new organic compounds, things which I cannot help considering in the same light as I do the infinite number of figures which may be produced by the caleidoscope.1

What would the world say of a man, who should take the trouble to shake for whole years that plaything and de[s]cribe minutely all the shapes (pretty as they might be) he had obtained from his operation!

You know, I am no great admirer of the present state of Chemistry, and of the Ideas leading the researches, made upon that field. Atoms, weight, ratio of quantities, endless

[p. 207]

production, and formula of compounds, i. e. the “caput mortuum” of nature, are the principal if not only subjects with which the majority of our Chymists know to deal. Force, power, action, life in fact, are, as it were, phantoms to them, disliked if not hated. The world being a system of Ideas, its very essence, power and intellect, how can we expect great things from men who so much mistake the nature of nature? In perusing what is written above I find it is not worth of being sent over the water, but having no more time to write another letter, you must take it as it is and excuse my random talking. Mrs. Schœnbein and the Children are well and beg to be kindly remembered to you. My best compliments to Mrs. Faraday and to you the assurance that I shall for ever remain

Yours
most truly

C. F. SCHOENBEIN.

❦

Notes

  1. 1This metaphor, we are informed, is one to which Schœnbein was very partial, in writing as well as in conversation. Passages from two letters to Liebig will suffice to bear this out. On September 5. 1853 he writes, after agreeing with Liebig that many fundamental facts are still required, if the scope of chemistry as an exact science is to enjoy a material expansion of its limits, as follow; “Now a days” he says “the results achieved are only the growth of facts of inferior importance, and the value we attach to the information thus acquired is hardly greater than what we would attribute to the production of novel combinations in the kaleidoscope.” Then again, on September 22. 1867 he says: “The aim of modern chemistry appears hardly apt to increase our knowledge of such phenomena. An infinite number of kaleidoscopic images, which the perseverence of chemists brings to light, after all, contributes but little to a better comprehension of chemical affinity, and adds but feeble information to the leading questions of the day.”

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 229 of the 1899 edition (printed page 205), showing letter 95.
Printed page 205 · scan leaf 229 of 408Open the full scan
Scan leaf 230 of the 1899 edition (printed page 206), showing letter 95.
Printed page 206 · scan leaf 230 of 408Open the full scan
Scan leaf 231 of the 1899 edition (printed page 207), showing letter 95.
Printed page 207 · scan leaf 231 of 408Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 95 of 158 · printed pp. 205–207 · scan leaf 229 of 408

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
The Letters of Faraday and Schoenbein, 1836–1862: With Notes, Comments and References to Contemporary Letters, with Notes, Comments and References to Contemporary Letters, 1899, pp. 205–207.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 82 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationSchœnbein to Faraday, 17 October 1852, “Schœnbein to Faraday.”. In The Letters of Faraday and Schoenbein, 1836–1862: With Notes, Comments and References to Contemporary Letters, with Notes, Comments and References to Contemporary Letters (Bâle: Benno Schwabe / London: Williams & Norgate, 1899), pp. 205–207. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/faraday-schoenbein-1899/95/.

BibTeX@incollection{faraday-schoenbein-1899-letter-0095,
  author    = {Schœnbein},
  title     = {Schœnbein to Faraday., 17 October 1852},
  booktitle = {The Letters of Faraday and Schoenbein, 1836–1862: With Notes, Comments and References to Contemporary Letters},
  publisher = {Bâle: Benno Schwabe / London: Williams & Norgate, 1899},
  year      = {1899},
  pages     = {205--207},
  note      = {With Notes, Comments and References to Contemporary Letters. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/faraday-schoenbein-1899/95/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/faraday-schoenbein-1899/95/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.