Faraday to Schœnbein.
If I do not write to you now I do not know when I shall…
Faraday to Schœnbein.1
Brighton 9 Decr. 1852
MY DEAR FRIEND
If I do not write to you now I do not know when I shall — and if I write to you now I do not know what I shall say — for I am here sleeping, eating and lying fallow, that I may have sufficient energy to give half a dozen juvenile Christmas lectures. The fact is I have been working very hard — for a long time — to no satisfactory end; all the answers I have obtained from nature have been in the negative, and though they shew the truth of nature as much as affirmative answers, yet they are not so encouraging and so for the present I am quite worn out. I wish I possessed some of your points
[p. 208]of character. — I will not say which, for I do not know where the list might end, and you might think me simply absurd and, besides that, ungrateful to Providence.
I had your letter by Dr. Whewell and I have received also your last of the 17th October and the paper and I hope when I return home to get the latter done into English. It is a very great shame to us that such papers do not appear at once in English but somehow we cannot manage it. Taylor appears to be much embarrassed in respect of the Scientific memoirs. I hope now that they have changed their shape and are to appear in two series, physical and chemical, that they will be more servicable to such as I am.
Your letter quite excites me and I trust you will establish undeniably your point. It would be a great thing to trace the state of combined oxigen by the colour of its compound, not only because it would show that the oxigen had a special state, which could in the compound produce a special result — but also because it would, as you say, make the optical effect come within the category of scientific appliances and serve the purpose of a philosophic induction and means of research, whereas it is now simply a thing to be looked at. Believing that there is nothing superfluous, or deficient, or accidental, or indifferent, in nature I agree with you in believing that colour is essentially connected with the physical condition and nature of the body possessing it, and you will be doing a very great service to philosophy if you give us a hint, however small it may seem at first, in the development, or as I may even say in the perception of this connexion.1
As I read your letter I wondered whether there was any connexion between your phenomena and those recently investigated
[p. 209]by Stokes.1 I do not mean any immediate likeness, but distant connexion. He has been rendering the invisible, chemically acting rays, visible2 — that is to say he has been converting them into visible rays. — You, by giving a given condition to a substance, make it, when in compounds, send one ray to the eye — and then by giving it another condition cause it to send other rays to the eye, the body being chemically the same. Both these are phenomena of radiation, and both are connected with chemical agencies or forces. If they could be connected, what a heap of harvests would spring up between the two. — I do not know enough yet of Stokes’ phenomona to form any thing but a crude idea and I know nothing of yours yet, so that you will think me very absurd to write such stuff; but then it is only to a friend.
You are very amusing with your criticisms on Organic chemistry.3 I hope that in due time the chemists will justify
[p. 210]their proceedings by some large generalisations deduced from the infinity of results which they have collected. For me I am left hopelessly behind and I will acknowledge to you that through my bad memory organic chemistry is to me a sealed book. Some of those here, Hoffman1 for instance, consider all this however as scaffolding, which will disappear when the structure is built. I hope the structure will be worthy of the labour. I should expect a better and a quicker result from the study of the powers of matter, but then I have a predilection that way and am probably prejudiced in judgment. My wife’s kindest remembrances to you and yours. My earnest wishes for the happiness of you all
Ever my dear Schœnbein
Your Affectionate friend
M. Faraday.
❦
Notes
- 1Bence Jones reproduces portions of this letter. in vol. 2. p. 292.
- 1That idea which continually governed Schœnbeins theoretical views was that the same matter, independently of its chemical character, is capable of acquiring diverse properties, under varying curcumstances. Proof of this is furnished by the change of colour at different temperatures; hence it is that he time and again reverted to questions of this nature.
- 1George Gabriel Stokes, professor of Mathematics at Cambridge was born in 1819 at Skreen, Co. Sligo, Ireland.
- 2“On the change of refrangibility of light,” Roy. Soc. Proc. 1850—1854. p. 195 and 333. “On the change of refrangibility of light and the exhibition thereby of the chemical rays,“ Roy. Soc. Proc 1850—1854. p. 259.
- 3He seems to have expressed similar criticisms to Grove, for in a letter dated Jan. 5. 1845 the latter writes: “I quite agree with the remarks at the close. I think chemistry is being frittered away by the hairsplitting of the organic chemists; we have new compounds discovered, which scarcely differ from the known ones and when discovered are valueless — very illustrations perhaps of their refinements in analysis, but very little aiding the progress of true science.” On the other hand he writes, after commenting on Becquerels process for extracting metals by voltaic means: “Who would not have been laughed at if he had said in 1800 that metals could be extracted from their ores by electricity or that portraits could be drawn by chemistry.” (Aug. 20. 1847.) We might also quote Graham’s views, which are contained in a letter to Schœnbein, dated Jan. 9. 1862: “Your very kind letter acknowledging receipt of my paper has afforded me much gratification; the more so, that the standpoint from which you have always surveyed chemistry, is high and philosophical. . . . The various modifications of oxygen (an element) which you have established, with the compounds into which they carry their properties are discoveries of a fundamental character, leading into new regions of science, quite aside from the routine chemistry of the day.”
- 1August Wilhelm Hofmann Ph. D. was born at Giessen in 1818. In 1848 he was professor at the Royal College of Chemistry in London; in 1865 professor at Berlin, where he died in 1892.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.



