Letter 95
THE experience of hundreds of years of civilization has shown that there are three things…
THE experience of hundreds of years of civilization has shown that there are three things which are pre-eminently useful in training young minds—Latin, Greek and mathematics—because they are, as I thought when first put at them, so abominably difficult. Certain processes in science, especially those which are reasoning processes, like mathematics or geometry, train the mind. So also of certain processes in mental and moral philosophy, and you might say the same of certain philosophical and interpretative ways of studying history. But these latter things are for you to advance into after you are more mature; they are rather too much for the early stages of youth, so that I think the old maxim, “Latin, Greek and mathematics for training,” remains as true as ever it was.
The reason it is so true is that language study and mathematics, especially geometry, were the first means which raised primitive men from barbarism, and we, when young or ignorant, are not at all different from barbarians. The same process must be gone through with us. The first step from barbarism is to invent an alphabet. Mere hieroglyphics or
[p. 101]picture writing won't do, because you cannot, with any efficiency, carry on a reasoning process with them on paper or parchment, or teach reasoning, and reasoning is mental training. You must have an alphabet and a good one like the Greek or Roman, and good signs for numbers, like ours. Our Arabic numerals and alphabet trained man's reasoning powers, as never before, took him out of barbarism because they trained him in use of words and numbers, taught him to think and reason efficiently. You can't think or reason without words and numbers, and the more you use them in complications and difficulties, the more your mind is trained. Nothing has ever been found that supersedes that method.
Nothing has ever been found equal to Latin and Greek for training the mind when in a young and pliable condition, because those two languages, being dead languages, are extremely difficult, and at the same time capable of most exact and logical meaning. They are the most remarkable languages of the world, the first civilized languages, the first languages that could be used in high intellectual processes; most modern civilized languages are made from them. A child cannot train himself so well in his mother tongue or a tongue that he learns from living with it, because he learns it too easily, by an instinctive primitive animal process. But to learn a dead language of such logical perfection as Latin and Greek requires a supreme mental struggle and effort which seems as if it would tear his poor little mind to pieces, and that is the reason it develops him.
This brings us to another important point. If you want the best result from education, do not try to make it easy. Make it hard. Train, train, train. Valuable information and culture courses by themselves merely produce loose thinking, sloppy inaccuracy, delusions, dreams, magnificient ideas and
[p. 102]speculations; and we have given our people so much of that sort that they are more easily duped, fleeced and fooled by humbugs and sharpers than any other people in the world. The strain and complications of modern life require trained minds more than ever.
Remember that your judgment is more important than your information. If you smother it in information it will be ruined. That is an advantage of manual training, use of tools on concrete things. They restore the primitive judgment. Men were largely developed in the past by using tools and thinking as they used them. Use your hands and tools all you can, even if they ruin your social position. Never ride if you have time to walk. Play all you can. Muscles hold up your nerves and the nerves hold up your mind.
I have nearly talked you to death, but one point more. No teacher can educate you. You educate yourself by your own mental or physical effort. The teacher can only guide and encourage you. So just work like blazes on the hardest things you can find.
Sydney G. Fisher
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.


