The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I

Edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910

165 letters of John Stuart Mill, written between 1829 and 1863, printed in 1910. Read from the printed page by machine, keeping its spelling and punctuation, each letter set beside its scan.

100/100 Reading scoreRead by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect a few slips.What this means

DownloadEPUB312 KBMarkdown728 KBTEI847 KB

1820s: 1 letter1830s: 31 letters1840s: 23 letters1850s: 58 letters1860s: 47 letters
1829–1863One lantern for each decade, longer where more letters survive.
The first letter in the book Clearly James Mill had been suffering from gout, for farther on in the same letter, Bentham offers to "come and sit with you, and help worship Mistink… Letter 1 Read it

The letters

1820s

1 letter
  1. 15 · IV · 1829India House Many of Mill’s earliest letters were written to John Sterling, who was afterwards made famous by Carlyle’s Biography. Sterling is described… 2To John Sterling

1830s

31 letters
  1. X · 1831India House You must have wondered at not hearing from me sooner; and not without good reason. It is true that I have not heard from you non plus, so… 4To John Sterling
  2. 30 · XI · 1831 To Gustave d'Eichthal. 5To Gustave d'Eichthal
  3. 24 · V · 1832London My dear Sterling,—The manner in which time passes over our heads without our perceiving it is quite frightful. 7To John Sterling
  4. 29 · V · 1832India House My dear Friend,—To be moderate, I will only thank you twice: once for being the first to write. The good-natured excuse which you make for… 8To Thomas Carlyle
  5. 17 · VII · 1832London My dear Friend,—Many thanks for your little note. I hope this letter will find all your perplexities at an end, and the paper on Goethe… 9To Thomas Carlyle
  6. 9 · III · 1833India House My dear Carlyle,—I ought to write oftener, though not exactly for the reason you jocularly give. I ought, and I would, if my letters were… 10To Thomas Carlyle
  7. 18 · V · 1833India House My dear Carlyle,—By this time you are again in your wilds, and have had time to feel yourselves at home and settled there, and you are… 13To Thomas Carlyle
  8. 5 · VII · 1833London I wrote a short letter to you intending to send it by your brother when he went to Craigenputtock; but he did not find time to call on me… 14To Thomas Carlyle
  9. 5 · VII · 1833 I am so far from seeing any intolerance in your dislike of speculation, unless it be either of the highest kind, or interesting for the… 15
  10. 12 · VII · 1833 . . . So much for these statesmen of ours—they always remind me of what Southey said to me at Keswick; pointing in a little Bible-book for… 16To John Sterling
  11. VIII · 1833 My dear Carlyle,—This note will be given to you by Mr. R. W. Emerson, of Boston (United States), who having been long a reader of your… 17To Thomas Carlyle
  12. 2 · VIII · 1833India House My dear Carlyle,—This letter will be, as you desire, extremely biographical ; I was conscious myself of a deficiency in that department in… 18To Thomas Carlyle
  13. 5 · IX · 1833India House chances to one that I should, but it is the twenty-first which has taken effect in reality. I was mistaken, too, when I said that if I went… 19To Thomas Carlyle
  14. 5 · X · 1833Mickleham, near Dorking, Surrey My dear Carlyle,—Two of your letters, both well deserving a better answer than this will be, have been waiting a long time for it; such as… 20To Thomas Carlyle
  15. 25 · XI · 1833India House My dear Carlyle,—As might have been anticipated, I found no time while at Paris to write to you, and though I have now been in London a… 21To Thomas Carlyle
  16. 22 · XII · 1833Kensington and expected, and in one sense waited for, a considerable time, for I had various matters of interest to write to you about, but as I hoped… 22To Thomas Carlyle
  17. 12 · I · 1834Kensington My dear Carlyle,—Your little note dated the 24th was evidently written before you received my letter written I forget when, but which I… 23To Thomas Carlyle
  18. 2 · III · 1834Kensington miscellaneous kind of a letter. I have a long arrear of little things to bring up, and, for the present, few great ones to say, and am in a… 24To Thomas Carlyle
  19. 28 · IV · 1834India House My dear Carlyle,—I received, a week ago, your little note—it had not escaped me that for an unusual length of time I had not heard from… 25To Thomas Carlyle
  20. 1835India House alterations in phraseology amount, as you will see, to but little—less than I expected—and you will probably think most of them trifling.… 26To Thomas Carlyle
  21. 7 · III · 1835India House to think as little as I can of this misfortune, though I shall not be able to cease thinking of it until it is ascertained how far the loss… 27To Thomas Carlyle
  22. 10 · III · 1835India House Yes, when the thing is again done, and I have realised the feeling of certainty that another volume is there, as true and as beautiful as… 28To Thomas Carlyle
  23. 23 · XI · 1836India House My dear Sir,—I have just returned from an absence of nearly four months on the Continent, rendered necessary by an obstinate though in no… 29To E. Lytton Bulwer
  24. 29 · XI · 1836 My dear Bulwer,—Accept my best thanks for the kind expressions in your letter. Nothing could be more gratifying to me than the whole tone… 30To E. Lytton Bulwer
  25. 1837 I have read your article with great eagerness and delight; it is such as I expected from you, and if we could have one such article in… 31To E. Lytton Bulwer
  26. 3 · III · 1838India House My dear Sir,—I have read the Monthly Chronicle with deep interest, and I hasten to make my acknowledgments to you for the feeling which… 32To E. Lytton Bulwer
  27. 5 · III · 1838India House In answer to your question, as to what I would be ready to do if my friends, as you call them, will not consent to what I think reasonable… 33To E. Lytton Bulwer
  28. 24 · VII · 1839India House second packet to know whether the article would suit me or not; and if I could have had any doubts, that packet would have removed them—the… 34To John Sterling
  29. 28 · IX · 1839India House no part of my vocation to be a party leader, but at most to give occasional good advice to such as are fitted to be so. Whether I have any… 35To John Sterling
  30. 2 · X · 1839India House I have read through with great interest the little volume lately published by Pickering, containing the Church and State and the Lay… 36To John Sterling
  31. 4 · XI · 1839East India House . . . Touching your question to me, whether I think that we know a sufficient number of laws of particular phenomena to be able to mount up… 37To John Sterling

1840s

23 letters
  1. 22 · IV · 1840India House My dear Sterling,—Your letter should have been answered when I first received it, which was just before I left Falmouth. The bustle and… 38To John Sterling
  2. 1 · X · 1840India House My dear Sterling,— . . . There is much more danger of war than people are aware of. More than one credible testimony of Frenchmen now in… 39To John Sterling
  3. 3 · XII · 1840 My dear Sterling,—I suppose this will reach you although directed only to the Torquay Post Office. I 40To John Sterling
  4. 19 · XII · 1840India House to throw himself upon, and no watchword to use but the old ones about making the Mediterranean a French lake, getting rid of the treaties… 41To John Sterling
  5. 5 · I · 1841India House My dear Sterling,—. . . About the war matters, I suspect we shall not make much of our discussion till we can carry it on by word of mouth.… 42To John Sterling
  6. XI · 1842India House I have been reading your review of Tennyson for the second time, after an interval of several weeks. I have found more difference than I… 43To John Sterling
  7. XI · 1842India House you are writing the sort of paper you mention. As to Tennyson, you were right in getting so much praise of him into the Quarterly by no… 44To John Sterling
  8. 27 · III · 1843India House praised my rather ambitious attempt, but I am very glad that you find enough in the book to repay the trouble of reading, and I shall be… 45To Sir E. Lytton Bulwer
  9. 26 · IV · 1843India House I do not write to you, my dear Sterling, with any such vain notion as of attempting to offer you any comfort under the double blow which… 46To John Sterling
  10. 29 · V · 1844India House My dear Sterling,—For some time after I heard of your last dreadful attack I was afraid to write to you, your father having given me what… 47To John Sterling
  11. 16 · VIII · 1844India House I have never so much wished for another life as I do for the sake of meeting you in it. The chief reason for desiring it has always seemed… 48To John Sterling
  12. 13 · IV · 1847 The notice in the Chronicle, to which I am indebted for your letter, was, as you supposed, mine. It is really a pity that all the trouble… 49To John Austin
  13. 30 · XII · 1847 Sir,—Your note of the 30th places Mr. Lovett's refusal to serve in the militia in a different light from that in which I had considered it.… 50To J. F. Mollett
  14. 27 · II · 1848 Dear Mrs. Austin,—I suppose by this time you are quite convinced that the English at Paris are not in the smallest danger, and that there… 51To Mrs. John Austin
  15. III · 1848 Dear Mrs. Austin,—I return to you Mr. Austin's letter. I never thought I should have differed from him so widely in feeling on any public… 52To Mrs. Austin
  16. 1848 Je vous ai adressé un exemplaire d'un traité d'économie politique que je viens de publier, et dans lequel je discute quelques unes des… 53To Armand Marrast
  17. 1848 Monsieur,—J'ai pris la liberté de vous adresser un exemplaire d'un traité que je viens de publier sur l'économie politique et sur quelques… 54To Eugène Sue
  18. XI · 1848 Dear Sir,—Permit me to return you my best thanks for your handsome present of the American edition of my “ Political Economy.” . . . 55To John Jay
  19. 22 · XII · 1848 Monsieur,—J'ai eu l'honneur de recevoir votre circulaire au sujet de M. Comte. Je vous envoie ci-joint un billet de 250 francs comme… 56To Emile Littré
  20. 22 · XII · 1848 Dear Mr. Grote,—A short time ago Comte, finding that his attempts to replace by private teaching the deficit in his income did not promise… 57To George Grote
  21. 1849 all your questions. I think you ought to allow me six volumes too; for if the questions occupy so many pages, what must the answers? I… 58To Dr. W. G. Ward
  22. 26 · IX · 1849 Sir,—Your letter, dated two months ago, has from various causes remained too long unanswered, and your present of the volume of your… 59To William Conner
  23. 1849 The stupid doctrines which alone the plan excludes, generally lie dead in the minds of children, having hardly any effect, good or bad—the… 60To W. J. Fox

1850s

58 letters
  1. I · 1850 Sir,—I have to acknowledge your communication of January 9th, inclosing a statement of the principles and objects of a proposed… 61To Edward Herford
  2. II · 1850 Sir,—I am sensible of the compliment paid to me by the promoters of the “Poor Law Reform Association” in their willingness to make some… 62To Edward Herford
  3. 22 · XI · 1850India House Since receiving your note I have read Mr. Kingsley's article. I think it an effective piece of controversial writing ; and as against the… 63To Walter Coulson
  4. 1 · II · 1851 Sir,—I cannot remain quite silent on the unjust and unfounded attacks made by the Dispatch on those whom it calls by the old-fashioned… 64To Editor of the Weekly Dispatch
  5. 28 · III · 1851India House acknowledgments to the Council of the Tenant League for the great honour they have done me by their proposal, communicated through you and… 65To F. Lucas
  6. 15 · V · 1851 Sir,—I hope I may be pardoned for addressing to you in this form rather than through the newspapers a remonstrance against the gross insult… 66To Sir George Grey
  7. 9 · VI · 1851 The prospectus says that the Review is to be “distinctly characterised by certain definite but broad principles”; but instead of laying… 67To John Chapman
  8. 7 · I · 1852 What the poor as well as the rich require is not to be indoctrinated, is not to be taught other people's opinions, but to be induced and… 68To H. W. Carr
  9. 18 · III · 1852 The pressure of my occupations has left me no leisure until now to answer your letter, and to thank you for the volume of your translation… 69To Adolph Soetbeer
  10. 20 · III · 1852East India House Though my references to your systematic work were confined to the Brussels translation, I am glad to say that I am able to read it in the… 70To Carl D. Heinrich Rau
  11. 8 · IV · 1852India House Dear Sir,— . . . I am much interested by what I know, both from yourself and otherwise, of your exertions to instruct and improve the… 71To Green
  12. 7 · VII · 1852East India House Dear Sir,—Your letter of 5th April has remained very long unanswered, but you are too well acquainted with the inevitable demands on time… 72To Rau
  13. 20 · III · 1853 you sent me is intended to meet a difficulty which has always appeared to me one of the chief stumbling-blocks of representative… 73To Lord Monteagle
  14. 15 · V · 1853India House Dear Molesworth,—My opinions on these subjects are very much the same with yours, except where they are mixed up with other subjects. I… 74To William Molesworth
  15. 7 · VIII · 1853Blackheath pamphlet on the Law of Partnership. Such subjects are not often discussed with so much closeness of reasoning and precision of expression… 75To Lord Hobart
  16. 13 · II · 1854 honour as that made in your letter of the 3rd respecting the chapter of my “Political Economy” on “The Future of the Labouring Classes.” I… 76To T. J. Furnivale
  17. II · 1854 I have received many letters which, like yours, ask me to explain or define particular passages of the “Logic.” I am not sorry to receive… 77To Arthur Gore
  18. 3 · III · 1854 Gentlemen,—A long absence from England has made me thus tardy in offering my acknowledgments to you and to the honourable bodies over which… 78To Library Committees, South Carolina
  19. 23 · IV · 1854 So far as I am able to collect the objects of the society from the somewhat vague description given of them in the prospectus, I am led to… 79To Neophyte Writers' Society
  20. 1 · VIII · 1854East India House Sir,—Having just returned from the Continent I find your note. I very much wish that it were in my power to refer you, or anyone, to a… 80To William Stigant
  21. 7 · VIII · 1854East India House Monsieur,—Votre lettre est arrivée à mon adresse pendant que j’étais en voyage et ce n’est qu’aujourd’hui que je suis à même d’y répondre. 81To Barbot de Chément
  22. 5 · XII · 1854Torquay My dear Sir,—I have been unable to answer earlier your note of the 10th of last month, having only found time to read the book you were so… 82To John M'Neill
  23. 11 · VII · 1855East India House Sir,—I beg to acknowledge the receipt of your pamphlet entitled “War Notes,” and of a letter asking my opinion of certain parts of it. I… 83To Wentworth Holworthy
  24. 1855 Almost the only biographical fact respecting Sir W. Molesworth which I am able to communicate beyond those which are known to the public is… 84
  25. 5 · XI · 1855Blackheath Dear Sir,—As you requested, I have tried to put on paper something if possible at once short and characteristic of our friend, and the few… 85
  26. 29 · IX · 1856 and fourth volumes are as popular at Adelaide as in London. They are, as you say, “pleasant reading but not exactly history.” His object is… 86To Arthur Hardy
  27. XI · 1856 Sir,—I beg to acknowledge your letter of the 3rd instant asking my objections to the address of the National Sunday League. The passage to… 87To Sunday League
  28. 24 · XI · 1856East India House Sir,—I have to apologise for the delay in replying to your letter of the 7th November requesting my opinion on your plan for the regulation… 88To the author of “Currency Self-Regulating and Elastic.”
  29. 13 · XII · 1856East India House Monsieur,—Votre lettre du 12 mai ainsi que les articles et brochures que vous avez bien voulu m’envoyer ne me sont parvenus qu’en… 89To Costantino Baer
  30. 30 · VI · 1857East India House J'ai tardé trop longtemps, mon cher M. Villari, à répondre à votre lettre du 15 avril. Aujourd'hui j'ai encore des remerciements à vous… 90To Pasquale Villari
  31. 12 · X · 1857East India House Dear Sir,—The little volume which you did me the honour to send me, arrived safely, but not until several months after the date of your… 91To Henry Carleton
  32. 22 · X · 1857Blackheath Dear Sir,—It is now some weeks since I received your letter of 23rd May, but I have not until now had time to answer your question. In… 92To F. Sinnett
  33. 11 · XII · 1857East India House I quite agree in the opinion that educated persons should count in a greater ratio than that of their mere numbers in the constituency of… 93
  34. 19 · I · 1858East India House Dear Sir,—I am very much obliged to you for sending me the paper which you read at the Birmingham meeting. I only knew enough of the Leeds… 94To John Holmes
  35. 21 · II · 1858Blackheath Park . . . When I began writing to you I thought that this country was meanly allowing itself to be made an appendage to Louis Bonaparte's… 95To Giuseppe Mazzini
  36. 9 · III · 1858East India House Mon cher Monsieur Villari,—Vos deux lettres dont la dernière porte la date du 10 janvier, mériteraient bien une réponse plus prompte. Je… 96To Pasquale Villari
  37. 20 · III · 1858East India House I have been turning over in my mind the proposal which was the subject of your note of the 17th, for founding a Professorship at King's… 97To William Newmarch
  38. 15 · IV · 1858East India House . . . Your project is a very good one if it could be successful. But of this there seems little chance. Even supposing the indifference of… 98To Giuseppe Mazzini
  39. 1 · VII · 1858East India House Sir,—I beg to acknowledge a letter from you dated 24th June. 99To J. Britten
  40. 8 · VII · 1858East India House Mon cher M. Villari,—Il y a bientôt trois mois que je dois une réponse à votre dernière lettre, mais vous savez comme je suis occupé et… 100To Pasquale Villari
  41. 8 · VII · 1858East India House spondent than I am, and I really do not know how many letters I have received from you since I wrote one. I am always busy and have been… 101To Judge Chapman
  42. 9 · VII · 1858Blackheath Park de n’avoir pas encore reconnu réception de votre excellent livre. D’abord je voulais le lire avant de parler, et plus tard je fus si occupé… 102To Louis Blanc
  43. 28 · XI · 1858Blackheath If I were to attempt to express in the most moderate terms what she was, even you would hardly believe me. Without any personal tie, merely… 103To George Grote
  44. 3 · III · 1859Blackheath Dear Sir,—Allow me to thank you for your very interesting treatise, which, having been absent, I have only just had an opportunity of… 104To James Lorimer
  45. 3 · III · 1859 Dear Sir,—Having been absent from home, it is only within the last few days that I have had an opportunity of reading and studying your… 105To Thomas Hare
  46. 6 · III · 1859 j'ai trouvé votre bonne et affectueuse lettre. J'y reconnais une sincérité de sympathie qui toujours soulage un peu le malheur dont elle ne… 106To Pasquale Villari
  47. 17 · III · 1859Blackheath Dear Bain,—I am glad that you like the “Liberty” so much and agree with so many of the heresies of the Reform pamphlet. With regard to the… 107To Alexander Bain
  48. 28 · III · 1859Blackheath Mon cher M. Villari,—Votre belle et touchante lettre m’a fait du bien. Je vous honore d’avoir su voir, au moins en partie, dans mes écrits… 108To Pasquale Villari
  49. 29 · III · 1859 Dear Sir,—I have long ceased to regard speeches in Parliament as meaning anything except that the speaker has not made up his mind to vote… 109To Thomas Hare
  50. 7 · IV · 1859 Dear Sir,—Many thanks for your letter. I should think the difficulty you had in obtaining a publisher was owing to the same cause which you… 110To James Lorimer
  51. 17 · VI · 1859St. Véran and particularly so to hear that you are going to have the opportunity of a public discussion at the Social Science meeting. What is wanted… 111To Thomas Hare
  52. 22 · VI · 1859St. Véran Mon cher Monsieur Villari,—Je ne vais pas renouveler notre discussion sur les affaires politiques. S'il dépendait de moi je ne voudrais pas… 112To Pasquale Villari
  53. 6 · VIII · 1859St. Véran Dear Bain,—Your letter of 11th July reached me in the Pyrenees, and I was pleased with all the news it contained, except what related to… 113To Alexander Bain
  54. 15 · X · 1859St. Véran . . . I am your debtor for an interesting letter, dated as long ago as 8th September. I am afraid I shall not be able to repay you in kind.… 114To Alexander Bain
  55. 14 · XI · 1859St. Véran article in the Edinburgh. It is a considerable thing to have got the editor to say that the experience philosophy and the association… 115To Alexander Bain
  56. 28 · XI · 1859St. Véran Dear Sir,—It gave me real pleasure to hear from you again after so long an interval, and I am much indebted to you for the opportunity of… 116To Dr. W. G. Ward
  57. 29 · XI · 1859St. Véran vous avez donné une excellente analyse de l'ouvrage. Vous en avez mis en relief les idées dominantes, vous avez assez appuyé sur chacune… 117To Pasquale Villari
  58. 20 · XII · 1859 I quite agree with you in expecting no benefit whatever from any Reform Bill likely to be brought forward by the present Government.… 118To Edwin Chadwick

1860s

47 letters
  1. 6 · IV · 1860St. Véran Mon cher Monsieur,—Je vous remercie beaucoup de l’envoi de votre nouveau livre. C’est un ouvrage très remarquable et qui me paraît même… 119To Charles Dupont-White
  2. 11 · IV · 1860 . . . I have read since my return here several things which have interested me, above all Darwin's book. It far surpasses my expectation.… 120To Alexander Bain
  3. 10 · VI · 1860Ax (Ariège) Mon cher Monsieur,—Votre bonne et intéressante lettre m'a suivi jusqu'à cet endroit charmant, digne d'une plus grande célébrité qu'il n'a… 121To Charles Dupont-White
  4. 18 · VIII · 1860Blackheath Park Dear Sir,—Your article has interested me very much and its main position is unshakeable, but I suspect we should differ greatly on a… 122To T. Cliffe Leslie
  5. 23 · IX · 1860Blackheath Park Dear Madam,—I have read your treatise, or rather the portion of it which you did me the honour of sending to me. If any part of your object… 123To a Correspondent
  6. 4 · X · 1860Blackheath Park Dear Madam,—I should have been very sorry to miss reading the sequel of your book. If when I had only read the first volume I was very… 124To the same Correspondent
  7. 6 · XI · 1860St. Véran Mon cher M. Villari,—Voici bien longtemps que je n'ai pas reçu de vos nouvelles, quoique ce soit moi qui ai écrit la dernière lettre. Ce… 125To Pasquale Villari
  8. 15 · I · 1861St. Véran Mon cher Beaumont,—Je viens d'achever la lecture da la correspondance et des opuscules et fragments inédits de Tocqueville. J'y ai trouvé à… 126To Gustave de Beaumont
  9. 1 · III · 1861Blackheath Park Dear Chadwick,—It is long since I have read anything on the subject of education which impressed me so much as the facts and ideas… 127To Edwin Chadwick
  10. 5 · VII · 1861Blackheath Park Your letter of 28th May came while I was abroad, and I have not hitherto had time to make the acknowledgment which is due to the feelings… 128To Sir Henry Taylor
  11. 4 · VIII · 1861Blackheath Park in the manner which he seems to suppose. I believe that I agree entirely with the views taken in Mr. Fawcett's article. But I do so… 129To John Chapman
  12. 20 · XII · 1861St. Véran this morning. It is an able, and will be a useful paper, and puts some points in a new and forcible way, though I differ from it on several… 130To T. Cliffe Leslie
  13. 10 · I · 1862St. Véran . . . I do not see that the opinions you express in your letter on practical ethics constitute any difference between us. I agree in them… 131To George Grote
  14. 22 · I · 1862St. Véran m’envoyer s’est trouvé être en effet le même que j’avais reçu il y a trois ou quatre ans. Il ne m’est pas pour cela inutile ; je suis en… 132To Célestin de Blignières
  15. 26 · I · 1862St. Véran J'ai lu avec le plus vif intérêt votre brochure. Elle soulève à chaque page des sujets de discussions et d'entretiens dont l'occasion… 133To Pasquale Villari
  16. 28 · I · 1862St. Véran your letter of 25th December. The reason is that I waited for the return from Paris of the only person I know here, who has in any degree… 134To W. T. Thornton
  17. 11 · VI · 1862Athens . . . I confess I am surprised that you attach any importance to Forster's or any other exhibitions of what they call spiritualism. Since… 135To W. T. Thornton
  18. 13 · IX · 1862St. Véran I should have much to say against several of your positions, and especially against your definition of liberty ; but I do not understand… 136To E. R. Edger
  19. X · 1862St. Véran, Avignon You will, I feel sure, be interested by a letter from this place, where I have been staying for a week, domiciled with our friend Mill. It… 137To Henry Fawcett
  20. 31 · X · 1862St. Véran Allow me to thank you most warmly for your long and interesting letter, which if it had been twice as long as it was would only have… 138To John Lothrop Motley
  21. 7 · XI · 1862St. Véran sociale qui s'avance à pas croissants en Russie, je la regarde comme un des phénomènes les plus importants d'un siècle déjà si riche en… 139To Nikolai Ogareff
  22. 24 · XII · 1862Blackheath Park . . . I have learned very much from the paper, and as far as I can judge there is only one point in it on which I have any doubt, viz., the… 140To George Finlay
  23. 24 · XII · 1862 Dear Sir,—I thank you very sincerely for your two letters, and for the important and most gratifying intelligence which they contain.… 141To Max Kyllman
  24. 24 · XII · 1862Blackheath Park I have not seen Bishop Fitzgerald’s publication, but you are quite right in supposing that what I wrote about miracles had not the smallest… 142To Joseph Napier
  25. 7 · I · 1863Blackheath Park and as it is a long time since I either wrote to you or heard from you, I think it is time to send you a bulletin from myself and to ask… 143To Alexander Bain
  26. 21 · I · 1863Blackheath Park The new volume of your Letters is, I think, at least equal to either of its predecessors. Like everything I have read of yours, it is both… 144To Samuel Bailey
  27. 26 · I · 1863Blackheath Park . . . Concerning the Alabama, most people of sense in this country are reserving their opinion till they hear what the Government has to… 145To John Lothrop Motley
  28. 27 · I · 1863Blackheath Park I have at your suggestion re-read the second chapter of the second part of the “Analogy,” and the result is somewhat different from what… 146To Joseph Napier
  29. 2 · II · 1863Blackheath Park which was both interesting and encouraging. I now write in high spirits on the subject of Greece, as to-day's newspapers for the first time… 147To George Finlay
  30. 3 · II · 1863Blackheath Park Sir,—I have had the honour of receiving your letter and the printed slips which you have been kind enough to send. These I have read with… 148To R. C. Wyllie
  31. 13 · II · 1863Blackheath Park Dear Bain,—I thought Ferrier's book quite sui generis when I first read it, and I think so more than ever after reading it again. His… 149To Alexander Bain
  32. 15 · II · 1863Blackheath Park acknowledged. The beginning you have made with the operatives on the subject of Mr. Hare's plan is most valuable. They are more open to… 150To Max Kyllman
  33. 23 · II · 1863Blackheath Park Dear Sir,—I duly received your letter of 2nd February, and I thank you for the favour you have done me by sending me the Christian Examiner… 151To C. A. Cummings
  34. 6 · IV · 1863St. Véran Dear Sir,—I am obliged to you for your letter, and am glad of the information it gives respecting the Working Men's Club and Institute… 152To Henry Solly
  35. 17 · IV · 1863St. Véran Dear Thornton,— . . . It was pleasant to receive a letter from you dated Marlow. I know not only the country but the house, and remember… 153To W. T. Thornton
  36. 23 · IV · 1863St. Véran Dear Sir,—Your letter of the 18th only reached me yesterday evening, on my return from an absence of nearly a week. 154To Theodor Gomperz
  37. 4 · V · 1863St. Véran . . . It does not seem to me that task-work, even if it could be made universal, would destroy the partial opposition 155To T. Cliffe Leslie
  38. 5 · VII · 1863Blackheath Park Our life, which has been more than usually broken in upon during the last month, owing to the presence of several persons in London whom I… 156To Theodor Gomperz
  39. 18 · VII · 1863Blackheath Park Dear Sir,—Want of time has prevented me from sooner acknowledging the present of your two works; as it still obliges me to postpone the… 157To J. G. Palfrey
  40. 23 · VII · 1863Blackheath Park Dear Sir,—Dr. Tyndall’s answer to your question must be considered, I should think, to set at rest all doubt respecting the complete… 158To J. Stuart Glennie
  41. 15 · IX · 1863St. Véran worth reading which came out on the gold question. If you have not yet returned to England you may not be aware of Fawcett’s paper read at… 159To T. Cliffe Leslie
  42. 24 · IX · 1863St. Véran Dear Sir,—Though I did not immediately answer your letter of 18th July it was by no means for want of being greatly interested by it. But… 160To Judge Appleton
  43. 23 · X · 1863St. Véran . . . Have you considered the subject of the taxation of charities? If not, perhaps when you do, you may not agree with Gladstone. I have… 161To W. T. Thornton
  44. 4 · XI · 1863St. Véran Your communication raises a great many more points than can be properly discussed in a letter, and more than I have time to discuss at all.… 162To Henry Chenevix
  45. 6 · XI · 1863St. Véran Monsieur,—Si j'ai tant tardé à vous remercier de l'envoi de votre important traité d'Economie Politique, c'est que j'ai dû attendre le… 163To Antoine Elisée Cherbuliez
  46. 14 · XI · 1863St. Véran think there is a great deal of valuable matter in them, and I would encourage you on every account to go on with your project. There is… 164To T. Cliffe Leslie
  47. 22 · XI · 1863St. Véran Dear Bain,— . . . I will read again Spencer's “Psychology.” I remember thinking his account of Extension very good ; and I shall be glad… 165To Alexander Bain

Undated

5 letters
  1. Clearly James Mill had been suffering from gout, for farther on in the same letter, Bentham offers to "come and sit with you, and help… 1
  2. Dear Sterling,—I have given a greater number of perusals to your note than I believe I ever gave to any epistle before. I should not… 3To John Sterling
  3. I know you too well to write to you of any subject except that of the great and truly apostolic work in which you are engaged, and to… 6
  4. India House I have allowed myself to be paralysed more than I should during the last month or two by these gloomy feelings, though I have had intervals… 11To Thomas Carlyle
  5. I should have availed myself of the opportunity you afforded me to make acquaintance with Leigh Hunt, did I not find it absolutely… 12

Colophon

About this edition

This edition reproduces The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot (London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910). It was read page by page by machine from the Internet Archive scan, keeping the printed spelling and punctuation.

Every printed page is included: 165 letters and 59 notes across 378 scan leaves, with the editor’s own pages between the letters. The text is in the public domain, and this transcription is free to reuse under CC BY 4.0, with credit to Paper Lanterns.

The frontispiece of the 1910 edition: Emery Walker Ph. sc.
Emery Walker Ph. sc.
scan leaf 10
The title page of the 1910 edition: The title page, 1910
The title page, 1910
scan leaf 2
Letters
165
Notes
59
Pages
378
Proofread by people
0%

Year by year

One stroke for each dated letter.

18301835184018451850185518601865

The book, page by page

All 378 leaves of the scan, in order: tall marks carry letters, middling ones the editor’s words between them, short ones the front matter, appendices and index.

  1. Frontmatterpp. 1–54
  2. CHAPTER Ipp. 55–90
  3. CHAPTER II 1833pp. 91–140
  4. CHAPTER III 1834-1844pp. 141–183
  5. CHAPTER IV 1847-1851pp. 184–224
  6. CHAPTER V 1852–1856pp. 225–253
  7. CHAPTER VI 1857-1859pp. 254–295
  8. CHAPTER VII 1860–1862pp. 296–332
  9. CHAPTER VIII 1863pp. 333–378

Take this book with you

The whole edition, free to keep and reuse, made from the same text you read here. The original scan is at the Internet Archive.

How this text was read

The text was read from the scan by a vision language model, a kind of AI that reads page images, and then checked page by page by machine. The error rate is low, but it is never zero. Until people have proofread every page against the scan, expect occasional slips: a dropped accent, a misread foreign word, a running head left in the text, a paragraph split where a page turned, a letter’s date or heading set in the wrong place.

When a letter matters to you, check it against the printed page beside it. What machines get wrong, and how the score is worked out

100 out of 100

Reading score from the machine checks.

  • Words, spelling and accents30 of 30
  • Letters, headings and page layout25 of 25
  • Footnotes joined to their places20 of 20
  • Every printed page present15 of 15
  • Downloads that open cleanly10 of 10

Proofreading

  1. Read by machinedone
  2. Checked by machinedone
  3. First reader0 of 378 pages
  4. Second reader0 of 378 pages

Help put it right

Paper Lanterns is a sister project of Akshara, the open library of Indian books. Akshara’s community exists for exactly this: people who care about keeping the written past readable, proofreading these pages one at a time until no slip is left. If that sounds like you, join them.

Set in Newsreader for Paper Lanterns, from a scan in the Internet Archive.