To Thomas Carlyle.

J. S. MillThomas Carlyle

My dear Carlyle,—I ought to write oftener…

9 · III · 1833India HousePrinted pp. 37–42

To Thomas Carlyle.

1833
—
Aetat. 26.

My dear Carlyle,—I ought to write oftener, though not exactly for the reason you jocularly give. I ought, and I would, if my letters were, or could be, better worth having; yet, even such as they are, not being altogether valueless to you, they shall become more frequent. Truly I do not wonder that you should desiderate more “heartiness” in my letters, and should complain of being told my thoughts only, not my feelings, especially when, as is evident from your last letter, you stand more in need of the consolation and encouragement of sympathy. But, alas! when I give my thoughts I give the best I have. You wonder at “the boundless capacity man has of loving”; boundless indeed it is in some natures, immeasurable and inexhaustible; but I also wonder, judging from myself, at the limitedness and even narrowness of that capacity in others. That seems to me the only really insuperable calamity in life—the only one which is not conquerable by the power of a strong will. It seems the eternal barrier between man and man—the natural and impassable limit both to the happiness and to the spiritual perfection of (I fear) a large majority of our race. But few, whose power of either giving or receiving good in any form through that channel is so scanty as mine, are so painfully conscious of that scantiness as a want and an imperfection; and being thus conscious, I am in a higher, though a less happy state, than the self-satisfied many who have my wants without my power of appreciation. You speak of obstacles which exist for others but not for me.

[p. 38]

1833
—
Aetat. 26.

There are many of earth's noblest beings, with boundless capacity of love, whom the falseness and halfness which you speak of have so hemmed round and so filled with distrust and fear that “they dare not love.” But mine is a trustful nature, and I have an unshakeable faith in others, though not in myself. So my case must be left to nature, I fear; there is no mind-physician who can prescribe for me, not even you, who could help whosoever is helpable; I can do nothing for myself, and others can do nothing for me; all the advice which can be given (and that is not easily taken) is, not to beat against the bars of my iron cage. It is hard to have no aspiration and no reverence but for an Ideal towards which striving is of no use; is there not something very pitiful in idle Hoping? but to be without hope were worse.

You see it is cold comfort which I can give to any who need the greatest of comforts, sympathy in moments of dejection; I, who am so far from being in better mental health than yourself, that I need sympathy quite as much, with the added misfortune that if I had it, it could do me no good. When you knew me in London I was in circumstances favourable to your mistaking my character and judging of it far too advantageously; it was a period of fallacious calm, grounded in an extravagant over-estimate of what I had succeeded in accomplishing for myself and an unconscious self-flattery and self-worship. All that is at an end, which is a progress surely. I would not now take the greatest human felicity on such terms.

But this is enough for the present in this strain; perhaps I may say more another time. Let me rather think of you, and what can be done to improve your environment. Your picture of Edinburgh is triste enough, and might serve, I fear, a fortiori, for all other provincial towns; there is an odour of literature and intellect about Edinburgh; at Glasgow, Liverpool, and the like, there is little else than the stench of trade. London is better, far better; bad though even it be. There are here, in infinitesimal proportion indeed, but in absolute number more than a very few, actual believers; some, whom I and even you could call true believers; to a

[p. 39]

1833
—
Aetat. 26.

very great extent, or entirely, among whom your thoughts would not fall like hand-grenades and put them to flight, but would at least be caught up and cherished, probably planted and reared into fruit. If you determine to leave Craigenputtock, there is surely no place so good as this, at least in the most important of all good things which locality can bring—kindred companionship. But you will have more things to consider, doubtless, than even that greatest of all, and you will not give that less than its proper weight.

I have no news to tell; the Reformed Parliament has not disappointed me any more than you; it is (as Miss Martineau, I understand, says of Brougham) so ridiculously like what I expected; but some of our Utilitarian Radicals are downcast enough, having deemed that the nation had in it more of wisdom and virtue than they now see it has, and that the vicious state of the representation kept this wisdom and virtue out of Parliament. At least this good will come out of their disappointment, that they will no longer rely upon the infallibility of Constitution-mongering; they admit that we have as good a House of Commons as any mode of election would have given us, in the present state of cultivation of our people. They are digging a little nearer to the root of the evil now, though they have not got to the tap-root. Read Roebuck's paper on National Education in Tait's last number; while you have the number in your hand, look at the first article in it, which is his also. He is narrow still, but the other Parliamentary Radicals are narrower—all but our friend Charles [Buller], who has the finest understanding of the set, but wants strength of will. For myself, I have well-nigh ceased to feel interested in politics. The time is not yet come for renovation, and the work of destruction goes on of itself without the aid of hands. If any man of clear insight were in Parliament just now, I hardly know what he could hope or aim at, unless to sow in some few of the more impressible minds the seeds of a renovation which will not be yet, nor soon. The Bad, God wot, is tumbling down quite as fast as is safe where there is nothing of

[p. 40]

1833
—
Aetat. 26.

Good ready to be put in its place ; what need of help in rolling the ball down hill ? I was wont to think that the benches of the House of Commons might be as a pulpit, from whence a voice might make itself heard further and more widely than even from your pulpit and mine, the Periodical Press. But what sort of a voice must it be which could be heard through all this din ? what were a single nightingale amidst the cawing and chattering of 657 rooks and magpies and jackdaws ? Truly, if there were not in the world two or three persons who seem placed here only to show that all is not hollow and empty and insufficient, one would despair utterly. It is only the knowledge that such persons have an actual existence on the same globe with us which keeps alive any interest in anything besides myself ; or even could I but believe that the good I see in a few comes not from any peculiarity of nature, but from the more perfect development of capacities and powers common to us all, and that the whole race were destined, at however remote a period either of individual or collective existence, to resemble the best specimens of it whom I have myself known, I verily believe, with that faith, I could be content to remain to eternity the solitary exception.

As for work, I have written perhaps of late not less than usual, but (except what has been already mentioned to you) nothing noteworthy that is likely to be soon published, except a notice for Tait of that book of Junius Redivivus, which same book you will soon receive in a parcel through Fraser, along with two articles of mine which I have formerly written to you about, sundry Memoirs of the French Revolution, the trial of the Saint-Simonians, and two letters which contain all I know of their subsequent proceedings and present state. (Those former books which miscarried have been traced to this house, though I have not been able to recover them.) My parcel for you at present waits only for William Fraser's permission to send you his copy of Levasseur's Memoirs, a permission too late applied for, and which has not yet reached me. Junius Redivivus will interest you, were it

[p. 41]

1833
—
Aetat. 26.

only for this, that he too is evidently a believer—a true believer, I think it may be said, so far as his faith has yet reached. There is vigour and a capacity of insight in him, and, if we may judge from the quantity he writes (the quality being never positively bad, and often very good), an altogether indomitable power of work. I have seen nothing of your writing for a long time. Cochrane,1 I see, has not yet printed your paper on Diderot. When shall we see it? deeply interesting it is sure to be. You know something of Fraser's Magazine: do you know, or can you guess, the authorship of a recent paper on Byron? It looks like the production of some half-fledged pupil of yours.

I have asked an instructed and clever Frenchman now here (one of the editors of the National) about the authenticity of those revolutionary portraits, to which I also am no stranger. He tells me that the genuineness of many of them is very doubtful, and without any hint from me he at once instanced Danton, some of whose relations he knows, and has seen authentic portraits. Danton, he says, was ugly, but not ignoble either in mind or feature, and the portrait in the collection wrongs him grievously.

As you conjectured, I have lost sight of poor Glen, only because I am utterly ignorant of his place of abode; at his old lodgings they believe him to be still in Scotland, with his brother and such other relatives as he may have. I therefore know not what to do with your letter. Poor fellow, it would have gladdened him to the very bottom of his soul to have received it, or but to have known that you had written to him; you probably have better means of discovering his whereabouts in Scotland than I have. Of our common friends or acquaintances I have little to tell. Austin is lecturing to fit audience though few, and will, I think, very probably go to live either at Berlin or at Bonn. He is still subject to his fits of illness, but they are, I think, less frequent. Mrs. Austin is very much as usual. Falk2 is not yet through the press. The Bullers are all in London;

[p. 42]

1833
—
Aetat. 26.

I fear they have lost money by failures in India, not enough to impoverish them, but any loss falls heavily on people who live up to their income.

I have heard nothing of Detrosier for a long time. I believe he has returned to Manchester with the intention of setting up a school, or else of continuing to go about lecturing on physical subjects, as he did formerly with some success.

Make my best remembrances to Mrs. Carlyle; I sometimes hear of her through Mrs. Austin. I do not say, “write soon,” but I know you will.—Yours ever faithfully,

J. S. Mill.

Notes

  1. 1[J. G. Cochrane, editor of the Foreign Quarterly Review.]
  2. 2[“Characteristics of Goethe,” from the German of Falk, &c.: translated by Mrs. Austin.]

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 91 of the 1910 edition (printed page 37), showing letter 10.
Printed page 37 · scan leaf 91 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 92 of the 1910 edition (printed page 38), showing letter 10.
Printed page 38 · scan leaf 92 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 93 of the 1910 edition (printed page 39), showing letter 10.
Printed page 39 · scan leaf 93 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 94 of the 1910 edition (printed page 40), showing letter 10.
Printed page 40 · scan leaf 94 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 95 of the 1910 edition (printed page 41), showing letter 10.
Printed page 41 · scan leaf 95 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 96 of the 1910 edition (printed page 42), showing letter 10.
Printed page 42 · scan leaf 96 of 378Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 10 of 165 · printed pp. 37–42 · scan leaf 91 of 378

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot, 1910, pp. 37–42.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationJ. S. Mill to Thomas Carlyle, 9 March 1833, “To Thomas Carlyle.”. In The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot (London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910), pp. 37–42. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/10/.

BibTeX@incollection{mill-letters-vol1-1910-letter-0010,
  author    = {J. S. Mill},
  title     = {To Thomas Carlyle., 9 March 1833},
  booktitle = {The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I},
  publisher = {London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910},
  year      = {1910},
  pages     = {37--42},
  note      = {Edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/10/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/10/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.