To Thomas Hare, · after Lord Derby's resignation, when Lord Granville was endeavouring to form a Cabinet.
and particularly so to hear that you are going to have the opportunity of a public…
To Thomas Hare,
after Lord Derby's resignation, when Lord Granville was endeavouring to form a Cabinet.
St. Véran, 17th June 1859.
Dear Sir,—I was very glad to hear from you again,
and particularly so to hear that you are going to have the opportunity of a public discussion at the Social Science meeting. What is wanted is to get the subject much written about and talked of, previously to which the theory that two and two make four was no doubt regarded as a paradox, and such people as Disraeli got up in public
[p. 221]places and attacked their political opponents for maintaining it. How I should have liked to have been there to answer him on the spot. But there was nobody to do it. I like your idea of writing a paper and sending it to the members of the Association; but am doubtful about attaching signatures to it. That foolish memorial to Lord Palmerston has thrown a wet blanket on the idea. I suppose you will give brief and pungent answers to the popular objections against the plan, which are only expressions in varied phrase of the popular inability to understand it. When there is anything definite in the objections the truth is generally the reverse of what is asserted. For instance, it is supposed that the plan would enable minorities to govern, whereas the fact is that now a minority very often governs (by being the majority of a majority), while under your plan a minority never could by any possibility do so. It is the only plan which ensures government by the majority.
I see no prospect of anything but mischief from the change of Ministry. Its effect on foreign affairs will be bad, and dangerously so, while reform will not be benefited. The new Cabinet will never be able to agree on anything but the well-worn useless shibboleths of Whig mitigated democracy, and besides, they will be unwilling to propose anything new from the certainty that the Tories would oppose it, would by misrepresentation rouse vulgar prejudices against it, and finally throw it out in the Lords. The Liberals by refusing to take the bill of the late Government as the foundation for theirs, have given redoubled force to the mischievous custom almost universal in Parliament that whatever one party brings forward the other is sure to oppose, whereby the enemies of change, even if very far from being a majority, are able to combine with the opponents and defeat the proposals of either. All parties seem to have joined in working the vices and weak points of popular representation for their miserably low selfish ends, instead of uniting to free representative institutions from the mischief and discredit of them.
1859
—
Aetat. 53.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

