To Alexander Bain.
article in the Edinburgh.
To Alexander Bain.
The Edinburgh article referred to in the following letter, was Mill's review of Bain's works, “The Senses and the Intellect” and “The Emotions and the Will.”
St. Véran, 14th November 1859.
Dear Bain,—I am glad that you and Grote like the
article in the Edinburgh. It is a considerable thing to have got the editor to say that the experience philosophy and the association psychology are getting up again, and to praise and recommend a book on that side of the question. I shall look with interest for Grote's article when he is able to write it. With regard to his Plato, one would be reconciled to the long time he spends over it if he were going to speak out his whole mind at last. But his timidity on the population subject is of bad augury. It would be easy enough to keep from any close contact with the physical part of the subject, and yet convey clearly enough all he means, or needs to say. But he seems to be
[p. 226]1859
—
Aetat. 53.
incurable. I have no doubt, however, that there will be much useful and improving matter in his book, and the longer he is in finishing it, the more thought there is likely to be in it when it is done. And with this I shall have to be contented, in default of better.
It is very pleasant to hear that you will be ready with the discussion of Phrenology and the science of character by next spring. It is an excellent plan to publish it in the first instance in Fraser, if Parker will take it. Besides being much earlier and more widely read, it will be an advertisement of the other volumes. I expect to learn a good deal from it, and to be helped by it in anything I may hereafter write on Ethology—a subject I have long wished to take up, at least in the form of Essays, but have never yet felt myself sufficiently prepared. I do not think of publishing my “Utilitarianism” till next winter at the earliest, though it is now finished, subject to any correction or enlargement which may suggest itself in the interval. It will be but a small book, about a fifth less than the “Liberty,” if I make no addition to it. But small books are so much more read than large ones, that it is an advantage when one's matter will go into a small space. I have not written it in any hostile spirit towards Christianity, though undoubtedly both good ethics and good metaphysics will sap Christianity if it persists in allying itself with bad. The best thing to do in the present state of the human mind is to go on establishing positive truths (principles and rules of evidence of cause included) and leave Christianity to reconcile itself with them the best way it can. By that course, in so far as we have any success, we are at least doing something to improve Christianity.
I have just sent to Parker for next month's Fraser a paper on Non-Intervention, in which there are some severe things said of Lord Palmerston's conduct in opposing the Suez Canal. That affair is damaging the character of England on the Continent more than most people are aware of; it is so direct a confirmation of the old and false ideas respecting the selfish foreign policy of England.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

