To Dr. W. G. Ward.
Dear Sir,—It gave me real pleasure to hear from you again after so long an interval…
To Dr. W. G. Ward.
St. Véran, 28th November 1859.
1859
—
Aetat. 53.
Dear Sir,—It gave me real pleasure to hear from you again after so long an interval, and I am much indebted to you for the opportunity of reading your first volume1 while still unpublished. I have read it all with great interest, much of it with sincere admiration and sympathy, and (what you probably care more about) with no little admiration also for the eminent Catholic writers whom you quote. Many of them I was already disposed to think highly of, but my knowledge of them was chiefly at second hand. The questions you put to me I will with pleasure attempt to answer. A candid adversary has as great a claim as a supporter to one's best endeavour for making one's meaning clear to him, even if no change of opinion is likely to result. I never feel so sure of doing good as when I find that my writings have given matter for thought to those who differ from me—a service which your treatise is well calculated to render, if I may judge from its effect on myself.
With regard to the passages in which I am mentioned (with the same good feeling which you have always shown towards me), my answer is that both Mr. Herbert Spencer and you have misunderstood me. When I spoke of inferences as necessarily following from premisses, I was not using the word necessary in its metaphysical, but in its popular sense. I meant neither more nor less than that the reasoning process is to us conclusive evidence of what it proves; take the testimony of our senses, which neither you nor I nor any one considers to be necessary in the philosophical sense. As soon as I read Mr. Spencer's criticism, I saw that I had given ground for it by an incautious use of the word necessary, which I endeavoured to correct in revising the book for another edition. My mistake was not so much in using the term in a double sense as in not giving proper notice that I did so. For
[p. 228]1859
—
Aetat. 53.
at that time I thought the word necessary a word worth retaining in philosophy; and I therefore, in conformity to my own rule (so to define words that their application may cover the same ground, and if possible even the same extent of ground, as before), used it as a designation for those properties of things which are deducible from the properties implied in their names. All mathematical truths, and truths analogous to mathematical, are in this sense necessary. As therefore I wished to keep the word necessary specifically for truths which are the results of reasoning, I was not unnaturally led into applying the term to the reasoning process itself. But (as I said before) I meant nothing in this case by necessity but conclusiveness.
I dare say you are not aware that in the last edition of the “Logic” I added a chapter in reply to Mr. Spencer, in which may be seen what I have to say against his own doctrine, but, if I remember right, I scarcely, if at all, touched upon his remarks on myself.
While I am on this part of the subject, I hope you will allow me to say that I do not think there is any ground for the distinction you draw between the evidence of present and that of past sensations, classing the one as experience and the other as intuition. If remembering were one act of the mind, trusting to memory another act, and judging that memory is to be trusted another, your distinction might be admissible. But they seem to me to be all three the same act, just as when I press my hand against an object feeling resistance, trusting the feeling, and judging that it is to be trusted, are all one. We cannot remember that which did not happen; no more than we can see or feel what does not happen. When I feel so and so, I cannot doubt that I do feel so and so, and when I remember to have felt so and so I cannot doubt that I did feel so and so. Memory I take to be the present consciousness of a past sensation. It is strange that such consciousness can exist, but the facts denoted by was, is, and is to come, are perhaps the most mysterious part of our mysterious existence, as is strikingly expressed in the well-known saying of St. Augustine. If I have made sufficiently clear what I
[p. 229]1859
—
Aetat. 53.
mean, I think you will see that it leaves in my apprehension nothing to be done by the intuitive act which your doctrine interposes. There indeed remains the act of generalisation which we perform when from remembering particular facts we ascend to the general proposition that memory may be trusted, in other words, that we have a faculty of memory; but this generalisation and classification of acts of our own mind has nothing in it contradictory to the experience doctrine, which always admits facts of internal consciousness as well as of external sensation, and considers the same logical processes as applicable to both.
Now, as to the still more important subject of the meaning of ought. I will endeavour to explain the sense I attach to it, though this cannot be done in very few words. I believe that the word has in some respects a different meaning to different people. We must first distinguish between those who have themselves a moral feeling—a feeling of approving and condemning conscience—and those who have not, or in whom what they may have is dormant. I believe that those who have no feeling of right and wrong cannot possibly intue the rightness or wrongness of anything. They may assent to the proposition that a certain rule of conduct is right; but they really mean nothing except that such is the conduct which other people expect and require at their hands, with perhaps the addition that they have a strong motive for themselves requiring the same from other people. This you will probably agree with, and I will therefore pass to the case of those who have a true moral feeling, that is, a feeling of pain in the fact of violating a certain rule, quite independently of any expected consequences to themselves. It appears to me that to them the word ought means that if they act otherwise they shall be punished by this internal and perfectly disinterested feeling. Unless they would be so punished, or unless they think they would, any assertion they make to themselves that they ought so to act seems to me to lose its proper meaning, and to refer only to the sentiments of others, or of themselves at some other time or in some other case.
[p. 230]1859
—
Aetat. 53.
If I am asked what is the nature of this feeling, and whence it comes, I do not think that it is exactly of the same nature or has exactly the same origin in all who have it. My father's theory of it, which you quote, seems to me a sufficient account of it as it exists in many minds. I certainly do not accept that theory as an exhaustive analysis of the phenomenon, yet I do not think your refutation, even of that theory, a sufficient one; inasmuch as the generation of a complex feeling from simple ones being a sort of chemical union, not a mechanical juxtaposition, it is quite to be expected that the compound will be to appearance unlike the elements it is formed from. The pains of conscience are certainly very different from those of dread of disapprobation; yet it might well be that the innumerable associations of pain with doing wrong which have been riveted by a long succession of pains undergone, or pains feared or imagined as the consequence of wrong things done, or of wrong things which we have been tempted to do (especially in early life), may produce a general and intense feeling of recoil from wrongdoing in which no conscious influence of other people's disapprobation may be perceptible.
However, I do not hold this to be the normal form of moral feeling. I conceive that feeling to be a natural outgrowth from the social nature of man; a state of society is so eminently natural to human beings that anything which is an obviously indispensable condition of social life easily comes to act upon their minds almost like a physical necessity. Now it is an indispensable condition of all society, except between master and slave, that each shall pay regard to the other's happiness. On this basis, combined with a human creature's capacity of fellow-feeling, the feelings of morality properly so called seem to me to be grounded, and their main constituent to be the idea of punishment. I feel conscious that, if I violate certain laws, other people must necessarily and naturally desire that I should be punished for the violation. I also feel that I should desire them to be punished if they violated the same laws towards me. From these feelings
[p. 231]and from my sociality of nature I place myself in their situation, and sympathise in their desire that I should be punished; and (even apart from benevolence) the painfulness of not being in union with them makes me shrink from pursuing a line of conduct which would make my ends, wishes, and purposes habitually conflict with theirs. To this fellow-feeling with man may of course be added (if I may so express myself) fellow-feeling with God, and recoil from the idea of not being in unison with Him. May I add that even to an unbeliever there may be a feeling similar in nature towards an ideal God? as there may be towards an ideally perfect man, or towards our friends who are no more, even if we do not feel assured of their immortality. All these feelings are immensely increased in strength by a reflected influence from other persons who feel the same.
1859
—
Aetat. 53.
This is the nearest approach I am able to make to a theory of our moral feelings. I have written it out, much more fully, in a little manuscript treatise which I propose to publish when I have kept it by me for the length of time I think desirable and given it such further improvement as I am capable of. Perhaps the short statement I have now made will convey some notion of what my opinion is, though a very imperfect one of the manner in which I should support it.—I am, very sincerely yours,
J. S. Mill.
Notes
- 1[“On Nature and Grace.”]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.




