To Alexander Bain, · recording Mill's first impressions on reading “The Origin of Species.”
. . . I have read since my return here several things which have interested me…
To Alexander Bain,
recording Mill's first impressions on reading “The Origin of Species.”
11th April 1860.
. . . I have read since my return here several things which have interested me, above all Darwin's book. It far surpasses my expectation. Though he cannot be said to have proved the truth of his doctrine, he does seem to have proved that it may be true, which I take to be as great a triumph as knowledge and ingenuity could possibly achieve on such a question. Certainly nothing can be at first sight more entirely unplausible than his theory, and yet after beginning by thinking it impossible, one arrives at something like an actual belief in it, and one certainly does not relapse into complete disbelief.
Another book I have been reading is Baden Powell's last,1 which, though much inferior to Darwin, is a wonderful book for a clergyman and an Oxford professor to write, and remarkable as an exemplification of one form of modern theism. It is curious to see natural theology reverting to the form in which it was conceived by Aristotle—that it is not what cannot be predicted, but what can, that proves an intelligent agency. There is in Powell's otherwise very consistent system an awkward gap at the point where this doctrine comes face to face with historical Christianity. What can he mean by holding that miracles are impossible, and yet that those of the
[p. 237]New Testament may be received as matter of faith, though not of science? Is the last a mere saving clause, as when Voltaire said nearly the same thing? If so, he must intend it to be seen through, as Voltaire did. But the general tone of his mind, so unlike Voltaire's, makes this improbable.
1860
—
Aetat. 54.
Notes
- 1[“Essays on the Order of Nature in Reference to the Claims of Revelation.”]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

