To T. Cliffe Leslie, the political economist.
Dear Sir,—Your article has interested me very much and its main position is unshakeable…
To T. Cliffe Leslie, the political economist.
Blackheath Park, 18th August 1860.
Dear Sir,—Your article has interested me very much and its main position is unshakeable, but I suspect we should differ greatly on a subject into which you do not
[p. 238]1860
—
Aetat. 54.
enter, that of the limitations. Though you do not say so, the whole of your reasoning seems to converge to the conclusion that all Europe (if not the whole human race) will some time or other be brought under one government. That there may one day be a kind of loose federation among the countries of Europe, and a common tribunal to decide their differences, is likely enough. But as for actual incorporation, when there is not identity of language, literature, and historical antecedents, I see no spontaneous tendency to it, nor any likelihood of its being brought about by that which has produced it heretofore, viz. conquest, which of all tendencies we ought most to execrate.
. . . . .
The generalities of Buckle's theory are very vulnerable, and I hardly think he could have held by them if any competent person had criticised them before publication. He could have afforded to part with most of them, for the premises are much broader than was required to support his conclusions, and it is exactly in this unnecessary margin and overplus of premises that, as it seems to me, the error lies.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

