To Sir Henry Taylor, · in reply to a letter from him criticising Mill's “Representative Government.”
Your letter of 28th May came while I was abroad…
To Sir Henry Taylor,
in reply to a letter from him criticising Mill's “Representative Government.”
Blackheath Park, 5th July 1861.
Dear Taylor,—
Your letter of 28th May came while I was abroad, and I have not hitherto had time to make the acknowledgment which is due to the feelings you express, and to the considerate and sympathising view which you take of what I have been endeavouring to do. I am very glad that my treatment of the subject, as a general thesis, has obtained so much of your approbation. With regard to its applicability to this country, and immediately, I am quite alive to the force of many of the considerations which you bring forward. You only state them as misgivings, and as misgivings I share most of them, though probably in a considerably less degree than yourself. On one thing we are almost sure to be agreed; that whenever the movement for organic change recovers strength, which may happen at any time, and is sure to happen at some time, it will make a great practical difference what general theories of constitutional government are then in possession of the minds of cultivated persons. It is as a preparation for that time that my speculations, if they have as much truth in them as you seem to think they have, may be valuable. In the meantime, while they keep up the faith
[p. 247]in possibilities of improvement, they tend rather to moderate than to encourage eagerness for immediate and premature changes of a fundamental character. If the opinions make any way, they will influence, more or less, what is done from time to time in the way of partial improvement, and while changes in right directions will be facilitated, the barriers will, I hope, be strengthened against those of a bad tendency. It is not to you that anything need be said on the necessity of keeping a true ideal before one, however widely the state of facts may differ from it, and the extreme peril, both of having a false ideal and of having no ideal at all; between which states (with a tendency at present towards the latter) politicians both speculative and practical seem to be divided.
1861
—
Aetat. 55.
I am very sorry to hear that your health imposes on you so much confinement. I hope that is the worst of the inconveniences it causes you. I too am not likely to forget the old days you remind me of, nor any of those with whom I used to discuss and compare notes, so agreeably and usefully to myself. If I have ceased to frequent them it is not from estrangement, but because society even of a good kind does less and less for me, and I have so much to do in the few years of life and health I can look forward to (though my health is now on the whole good), that I really have no time to spare for anything but what is at once absolutely necessary to me, and the only thing besides reading which is a real relaxation, active outdoor exercise. I do not, however, give up the hope of again seeing you, and to do so will always be a pleasure.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

