To Thomas Carlyle
My dear Carlyle,—By this time you are again in your wilds…
To Thomas Carlyle
India House, 18th May 1833.
1833
—
Aetat. 26.
My dear Carlyle,—By this time you are again in your wilds, and have had time to feel yourselves at home and settled there, and you are expecting a letter from me— and I have two to acknowledge and, if so might be, to repay. I have many things to say, too ; at least they seem many before I begin to say them; they will seem few before I have done. First, then, I have read your paper on Diderot. Of the man, and of his works and of his contemporaries, so far as I think at all, I think very much as you do ; yet I have found more to differ from in that article of yours than in anything of your writing I commonly do. The subject seems to have carried you, and me as your reader, over a range of topics on which there has always been a considerable extent of undiscussed and unsifted divergence of opinion (pardon this galimatias of mixed metaphor) between us two ; on some of which, too, I sometimes think that the distance has rather widened than narrowed of late. That may be my loss, and my fault ; at all events, it seems to me that there has been on my part something like a want of courage in avoiding, or touching only perfunctorily, with you, points on which I thought it likely that we should differ. That was a kind of reaction from the dogmatic disputatiousness of my former narrow and mechanical state. I have not any great notion of the advantage of what the “free discussion” men call the “collision of opinions,” it being my creed that Truth is sown and germinates in the mind itself, and is not to be struck out suddenly like fire from a flint by knocking another hard body against it : so I accustomed myself to learn by inducing others to deliver their thoughts, and to teach by scattering my own, and I eschewed occasions of controversy (except occasionally with some of my old Utilitarian associates). I still think I was right in the main, but I have carried both my doctrine and my practice much too far ; and this I know by one of
[p. 48]1833
—
Aetat. 26.
its consequences, which I suppose would be an agreeable one to most men, viz., that most of those whom I at all esteem and respect, though they may know that I do not agree with them wholly, yet, I am afraid, think, each in their several ways, that I am considerably nearer to agreeing with them than I actually am. In short, I know that I have been wrong, by finding myself seated in the gig much more firmly than I have any business as an honest man to be. So you see I am only about to have, in all its fullness, that sincerity of speech for which you give me credit. I only had it thus far hitherto, that all I have ever spoken, by word of mouth or in writing, I have firmly believed, and have spoken it solely because it was my belief. Yet even that, in these days, was much, but not enough, seeing that it depends upon my own will to make it more. The result of all which is that with you, as well as with several others very unlike you, there will probably be a more frequent and free communication of dissent than has hitherto been, even though the consequence should be to be lowered in your opinion ; that, indeed, if it were to be the result, would be conclusive proof that I have been acting wrongly hitherto, because it would show that for being thought so highly of I had been partly indebted to not being thoroughly known—which I am sure is the case oftener than I like to think of.
You see there will be so much the more to talk over when we meet ; and that will be this summer, unless, which is always possible, I should not be in a state of mind in which meeting with any one is profitable or delightful to me. I believe I am the least helpable of mortals—I have always found that when I am in any difficulty or perplexity of a spiritual kind I must struggle out of it by myself. I believe, if I could, whenever anything is spiritually wrong with me, I should shut myself up from the human race, and not see face of man until I had got firm footing again on some solid basis of conviction, and could turn what comes into me from others into wholesome nutriment. I am often in a state almost of scepticism, and have no theory of Human Life at all, or
[p. 49]1833
—
Aetat. 26.
seem to have conflicting theories, or a theory which does not amount to a belief. This is only a recent state, and, as I well know, a passing one, and my convictions will be firmer and the result of a larger experience when I emerge from this state than before; but I have never found any advantage in communion with others while my own mind was unsettled at its foundations, and if I am not much mended when my vacation time comes round, I will rather postpone a meeting with you until I am.
I have neither written nor read much since I last wrote you, except one or two trifling things in the Examiner; including, however, one of a somewhat more weighty kind (though not much), which you will see in a week or more now, because I begin to see some things a little clearer, though many things which I once thought I understood, I now believe cannot be known with true insight, but by means of faculties which cannot be acquired, and which to me have not been given, save in most scanty measure. Alison's book, which I asked you about, I have procured and read; the man is quite inconceivably stupid and twaddling, I think, beyond anybody who has attempted to write elaborately on the subject. He has no research; the references with which he loads his margin are chiefly to compilations. I could write something about him, or rather about his subject; but I could employ myself better, unless there were some widely-circulated periodical that would publish it: the Edinburgh Review perhaps would, were it not that I should wish to show up Macaulay's ignorance of the subject and assumption of knowledge, as shown in that very Review.
The long-missing parcel of books has at length turned up, and I have received intimation that the second is at Longman's. I did not mean you to return those Repositories, but they are not, to you, worth my sending back again. Keep all I send you henceforth. On learning that my parcel was not in time for Fraser's monthly packet (which I thought I had taken care that it should be), I sent two more numbers of the Repository to be added to it, in one of which is the article I told you of, concerning
[p. 50]1833
—
Aetat. 26.
Junius Redivivus. The passage you saw quoted about books and men was from that; so there is not evidence therein of “another Mystic”: so much the worse. I was much interested by learning that your recent thoughts have been so nearly of the same kind; tell me what you have thought since, especially since you have thought of the question practically, as altering your own future choice of a mode of activity. The difficulty of comparing two magnitudes and distinguishing which is greatest, is, as we all know, vastly enhanced when the magnitudes themselves are of almost infinitesimal smallness, and that unhappily seems to be the case at present with the portion of good, that one can see clearly a prospect of achieving in any course that one can take; yet it seems to me that if one had a proper stage and proper tools, more is to be accomplished just now by the doer of the deed than by the sayer of the word —words are so little listened to now but when they are the prelude or the accompaniment to some deed; my word, again, is partly intelligible to many more persons than yours is, because mine is presented in the logical and mechanical form which partakes most of this age and country, yours in the artistical and poetical (at least in one sense of those words, though not the sense I have been recently giving them) which finds least entrance into any minds now, except when it comes before them as mere dilettantism and pretends not to make any serious call upon them to change their lines. But then, what career is open to the doer, if either in your position or in mine? Write to me what has been passing in you on this matter, whether of a general kind or as affecting yourself individually.
I am sure I have twenty other things to say, but cannot think of them at this instant; I shall write again the sooner. Let me ask you this one question. Have you seen the book published by the Poor Law Commissioners? If you have not, let me send it to you. Often you have complained how little of the state of a people is to be learned from books; much is to be learned of it from that book, both as to their physical and their spiritual state. The result is
[p. 51]1833
—
Aetat. 26.
altogether appalling to the dilettanti, and the gigmen, and the ignorant and timid in high stations ; to me it has been, and will be I think to you, rather consoling, because we knew the thing to be unspeakably bad : but this I think shows that it may be considerably mended with a considerably less amount of intellect, courage, and virtue in the higher classes, than had hitherto appeared to me to be necessary. Any way the book cannot fail to interest you, because any authentic information as to any human thing is interesting to you. I regard this inquiry with satisfaction under another [aspect ?] as great too—that it has been more honestly and more ably performed than anything which has been done under the authority of Government since I remember ; and has, in consequence, been the means of getting some of the best men I know, for such purposes, put into other work of the same kind, and decidedly embarked in the same career. You will find among them my friend John Wilson, whom you have seen ; he is now Secretary to the Factory Commission. Chadwick 1 also, the ablest of them all, may be said to be at the head of that Commission. I know not of any news to tell ; I have seen little of Fonblanque lately. The Austins are still bent upon going to live in Germany after the conclusion of his present course of Lectures. At the Literary Union I can learn no more of Glen than I knew before. Kindest remembrances to Mrs. Carlyle.
Charles Buller is well, and in spirits, and increasingly disposed to work ; he will not be lost, it were pity he should : his career will be politics, I think ; not the best career, far from that, but he will, I now think, demean himself therein like a true man : his superiority to all those people is even now, little as he has yet done, beginning to be felt, and he is gaining influence which will enable him to utter such truth as is in him with some certainty of being listened to—he is pure-minded, and not a self-seeker, I am sure of that.
Notes
- 1[Afterwards Sir Edwin Chadwick.]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.




