To the Right Hon. Joseph Napier, · who afterwards became Lord Chancellor of Ireland, and received a baronetcy. This is in reply to a letter on the subject of Mill’s criticism of Butler’s “Analogy” in his “Logic.”
I have not seen Bishop Fitzgerald’s publication…
To the Right Hon. Joseph Napier,
who afterwards became Lord Chancellor of Ireland, and received a baronetcy. This is in reply to a letter on the subject of Mill’s criticism of Butler’s “Analogy” in his “Logic.”
Blackheath Park, 24th December 1862.
Dear Sir,—I have had the honour of receiving your letter of 22nd December.
I have not seen Bishop Fitzgerald’s publication,1 but you are quite right in supposing that what I wrote about miracles had not the smallest reference to Butler, but only to the writers who professed to reply to Hume, and especially Campbell. It is many years since I read
[p. 270]1862
—
Aetat. 56.
or looked into the “Analogy,” and I cannot at present remember whether my remarks apply even partially to anything said by Butler. That in their main scope they are inapplicable to him is evident, since it appears from your letter that he fully recognised the distinction between improbability on the doctrine of chances and improbability in the only sense which constitutes incredulity.
My view of the general question is briefly this: that a miracle, considered merely as an extraordinary fact, is as susceptible of proof as other extraordinary facts: that, as a miracle, it cannot in the strict sense be proved, because there never can be conclusive proofs of its miraculous nature; but that to any one who already believes in an intelligent creator and ruler of the universe the moral probability that a given extraordinary event (supposed to be fully proved) is a miracle, may greatly outweigh the probability of its being the result of some unknown natural cause.
Notes
- 1[His edition of Butler’s “Analogy.”]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

