To W. T. Thornton, · in reply to a criticism of his on the “Utilitarianism.”

John Stuart MillW. T. Thornton

Dear Thornton,— . . . It was pleasant to receive a letter from you dated Marlow.

17 · IV · 1863St. VéranPrinted pp. 291–292

To W. T. Thornton,
in reply to a criticism of his on the “Utilitarianism.”

Dear Thornton,— . . . It was pleasant to receive a letter from you dated Marlow. I know not only the country but the house, and remember well its view over that beautiful valley. I am glad that I have carried you with me to so great an extent on the subject of Utilitarianism. What you say respecting the supposed case of Iphigenia does not at all contradict my opinion, as I never contended that the feeling of justice originates in a consideration of general

[p. 292]

1863
—
Aetat. 56.

utility, though I think it is that consideration which gives it its binding and properly moral character, and you yourself seem to think that in such a case as the one you suppose, the feeling of justice ought to yield to general utility. More than this no utilitarian can possibly ask. But I am inclined to think that such a case cannot possibly arise, and that the feeling of justice (except where, being divided against itself, it can be appealed to on both sides) never need come into conflict with the dictates of utility. The case of Iphigenia was one of supposed religious duty, which, where it intervenes, takes away the conflict, by removing the sense of moral wrong from the sacrifice. The nearest approach to it that occurs to me within the purely social or political sphere is the case of a people required by a powerful enemy under penalty of extermination to surrender some distinguished citizen, say the Carthaginians in the case of Hannibal. Now, in such a case as this I think there can be no doubt that the morality of utility requires that the people should fight to the last rather than comply with the demand ; not only because of the special tie between the community and each of its members, and between the community and a benefactor, who, in the case supposed, is demanded as a victim precisely because of the greatness of his services, but also for a more general reason—namely, the reason which makes it right that a people inferior in strength should fight to the death against the attempt of a foreign despot to reduce it to slavery. For such iniquitous attempts, even by powers strong enough to succeed in them, are very much discouraged by the prospects of meeting with a desperate though unsuccessful resistance. The weak may not be able finally to withstand the strong if these persist in their tyranny, but they can make the tyranny cost the tyrant something, and that is much better than letting him indulge it gratis.

I think such a case as that of Hannibal comes within these reasons, and indeed is a mere case of the same principle.

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 353 of the 1910 edition (printed page 291), showing letter 153.
Printed page 291 · scan leaf 353 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 354 of the 1910 edition (printed page 292), showing letter 153.
Printed page 292 · scan leaf 354 of 378Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 153 of 165 · printed pp. 291–292 · scan leaf 353 of 378

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot, 1910, pp. 291–292.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationJohn Stuart Mill to W. T. Thornton, 17 April 1863, “To W. T. Thornton, · in reply to a criticism of his on the “Utilitarianism.””. In The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot (London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910), pp. 291–292. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/153/.

BibTeX@incollection{mill-letters-vol1-1910-letter-0153,
  author    = {John Stuart Mill},
  title     = {To W. T. Thornton, · in reply to a criticism of his on the “Utilitarianism.”, 17 April 1863},
  booktitle = {The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I},
  publisher = {London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910},
  year      = {1910},
  pages     = {291--292},
  note      = {Edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/153/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/153/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.