To John Sterling
no part of my vocation to be a party leader…
To John Sterling
India House, 28th September 1839.
My dear Sterling,—I quite think with you that it is
no part of my vocation to be a party leader, but at most to give occasional good advice to such as are fitted to be so. Whether I have any better vocation for being a philosopher, or whether you will think so when you see what I am capable of performing in that line, remains for the future to decide. I hope to give materials for the decision before long, as I can hardly fail, I think, to finish my “ Logic ” in the course of next year. I have endeavoured to keep clear, as far as possible, of the controversy respecting the perception of the highest Realities by direct intuition, confining Logic to the laws of the investigation of truth by means of extrinsic evidence, whether ratiocinative or inductive. Still, I could not avoid conflict with some of the subordinate parts of the supernatural philosophy which, for aught I know, may be as necessary to it as what may
[p. 114]1839
—
Aetat. 33.
appear to me its fundamental principles and its only important results. I doubt, therefore, whether I can expect anything but opposition from the only school of metaphysical speculation which has any life or activity at present. But nous verrons. I have, at all events, made many things much clearer to myself than they were before—and that is something, even if I am satisfied to be my own only disciple.
I am very far from agreeing, in all things, with the “Analysis,”1 even on its own ground—though perhaps, from your greater distance, the interval between me and it may appear but trifling. But I can understand your need of something beyond it and deeper than it, and I have often had moods in which I would most gladly postulate, like Kant, a different ultimate foundation, “subjectiver bedürfnisses willen” if I could.
Notes
- 1[James Mill’s “Analysis of the Human Mind.”]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

