To John Sterling, · on Coleridge.
I have read through with great interest the little volume lately published by Pickering…
To John Sterling,
on Coleridge.
India House, 2nd October 1839.
My dear Sterling,— . . .
I have read through with great interest the little volume lately published by Pickering, containing the Church and State and the Lay Sermons. In the former I see more and more to admire, though I think, there and elsewhere, he runs riot with the great historical conception of a certain idea of the scope and fitting attributes of some social element, working in the minds of people from age to age without distinct consciousness on their part. This, I am aware, is the natural result of his system of metaphysics, but I, who do not believe in pre-existent ideas, see in as much as is true of this doctrine (and that much of it is true I contend as strongly as he) only the first confused view suggested by our various instincts, of the various wants of society and of the mutual co-relation of these. On the particular doctrines of his political philosophy, it seems to me that he
[p. 115]1839
—
Aetat. 33
stands almost alone in having seen that the foundation of the philosophy of the subject is a perception what are those great interests (comprehending all others) each of which must have somebody bound and induced to stand up for it in particular, and between which a balance must be maintained—and I think with him that those great interests are two, permanence and progression. But he seems to me quite wrong in considering the land to be essentially identified with permanence, and commercial wealth with progression. The land has something to do with permanence, but the antithesis, I think, is rather between the contented classes and the aspiring—wealth and hopeful poverty—age and youth—hereditary importance and personal endowments. As I think the Church and State the best, so the Lay Sermons seem to me the worst of Coleridge's writings yet known to me, though there are excellent passages in them.
I think exactly as you do about the doctrine which resolves the pleasure of music into association. I seem to myself to perceive clearly two elements in it, one dependent on association, the other not—and those elements combined in very varying proportions, as, e.g., the former preponderating in Gluck and Beethoven, the latter in Mozart.
As I finish this letter, behold a note from Carlyle. He says: “Sterling's is a splendid article; in spite of its enormous extravagance some will like it, many are sure to talk of it and on the whole be instructed by it. No man in England has been better reviewed than I—if also no one worse.” So far so good; and as for the “extravagance,” I doubt not his modesty applies that appellation mainly to the praise.
I heard from Mr. Sterling yesterday more than I liked to hear about the state of your health, though I trust not enough to inspire any serious apprehension. Do take care of yourself, for you can ill be spared publicly or privately, and by few (out of your own family) so ill as by yours
affectionately,
J. S. Mill.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

