To John Austin, the eminent jurist.
The notice in the Chronicle, to which I am indebted for your letter, was, as you supposed…
To John Austin, the eminent jurist.
13th April 1847.
1847
—
Aetat. 40.
Dear Mr. Austin,—There is no occasion to send anything you may write to me by any circuitous channel. If I did pay postage I should not grudge it for your letters, but in fact I do not. The India House pays all my letters, except penny post letters which everybody pays before sending.
The notice in the Chronicle, to which I am indebted for your letter, was, as you supposed, mine. It is really a pity that all the trouble you must have taken with the article on Centralisation should have produced nothing more than a review article.
I am very glad that you should write anything whatever; but I hope, especially now, when your pecuniary affairs are settled in the manner you desire, that you will rather write books than reviews. An entirely unknown person, whose books no one would read, must begin by reviews, but you have written a book which, for the kind of book, has been very successful, and what you write is more likely to be read with your name than without it. A book gives much more scope than a review for your peculiar forte, the analysis of a subject down to its ultimate scientific elements. A review is not a slight thing to you, and you take the same pains with it as you would with a scientific treatise, which, in fact, it is; and all who can be benefited by it at all would prefer to have it in a permanent form. It seems to me that reviews have had their day, and that nothing is now worth much except the two extremes, newspapers for diffusion and books for accurate
[p. 129]1847
—
Aetat. 40.
thought. Every thinker should make a point of either publishing in his life if possible, or at any rate leaving behind him the most complete expression he can produce of his best thoughts, those which he has no chance of getting into any review. There are two books I have heard you speak of as projects; a continuation of “The Province of Jurisprudence,” that is, in fact, a publication and completion of your lectures: this would be the easiest to you, so much of it being already done: the other, which would be more important, is a systematic treatise on morals. This last may wait long for any one with the intellect and the courage to do it as it should be done. And until it is done we cannot expect much improvement in the common standard of moral judgments and sentiments.
Of the two subjects you mention in your letter, the “Province of Government” is no doubt important in itself, and peculiarly a question of the present time. I have necessarily thought a great deal about it lately for the purposes of a practical treatise on Political Economy, and I have felt the same difficulty which you feel about the axiomata media. I suspect there are none which do not vary with time, place, and circumstance. I doubt if much more can be done in a scientific treatment of the question than to point out a certain number of pros and a certain number of cons of a more or less general application, and with some attempt at an estimation of the comparative importance of each, leaving the balance to be struck in each particular case as it arises. But that subject is, I think, tolerably safe as far as theory is concerned, for the thinking minds of the Continent and of England have fairly thought up to it, and it is sure to be amply discussed and meditated upon for the next ten or twenty years. It is hardly a subject for any one who is capable of things much in advance of the time.
On the other subject, “The Antecedents of the Revolution,” I much doubt if what you propose to write will do any good to those whom you hope to influence by it. I think with you that the English higher classes (of the
[p. 130]1847
—
Aetat. 40.
German I know nothing) mean well, “what little they do mean,” as my father said of some person. They have grown good even to goodness, as they show every year more and more. But also every year shows more and more their pitoyable absence of even that very moderate degree of intellect, and that very moderate amount of will and character which are scattered through the other classes, but of which they have certainly much less than the average share owing to the total absence of the habit of exerting their minds for any purpose whatever. I used to hope, as my father did (with all his democratic predilections), that when their political monopoly was taken away they would be induced to exert themselves in order to keep ahead of their competitors, but I have quite ceased to think so. If there is anything of which experience convinces me more and more it is that, beyond a certain point, facilities, as they are called, are hindrances, and that the more the path to any meritorious attainment is made smooth to an individual or a class, from their early youth, the less chance there is of their realising it. Never to have had any difficulties to overcome seems fatal to mental vigour. The doctrine of averting revolutions by wise concessions to the people does not need to be preached to the English aristocracy. They have long acted on it to the best of their capacity, and the fruits it produces are soup-kitchen and tea-house bills.
As far as I see, the influence of democracy on the aristocracy does not operate by giving them any of the strength of the people, but by taking away that which was their own; making them bend with a willing submission to the yoke of bourgeois opinion in all private things, and be the slaves, in public matters, of the newspapers which they dislike and fear. I confess I look less and less to that quarter for anything good. Whatever is valuable in the traditions of gentlemanhood is a fait acquis to mankind; as it is really grounded on the combination of good policy in the correct intellectual perceptions, it will always be kept alive by really cultivated persons; the most complete parvenus now in this country have as much of it as people
[p. 131]1847
—
Aetat. 40.
of family, and for its diffusion must not our real reliance be on the extension and improvement of education? I have even ceased to think that a leisured class, in the ordinary sense of the term, is an essential constituent of the best form of society. What does seem to me essential is that society at large should not be overworked, nor over-anxious about the means of subsistence, for which we must look to the grand source of improvement, repression of population, combined with laws or customs of inheritance which shall favour the diffusion of property instead of its accumulation in masses.
It is, I dare say, very natural that, living in France, you should be much impressed with the unfavourable side of a country that has passed through a series of revolutions. The inordinate impulse given to vulgar ambition, down to even a low class, and the general spirit of adventureship are, I have no doubt, disgusting enough ; but may not much of them be ascribed to the mere accident of the brilliant fortune of a certain lieutenant of artillery (as Stendhal says), and much to the habitual over-governing by which power and importance are too exclusively concentrated upon the Government and its functionaries? In England, on the contrary, I often think that a violent revolution is very much needed, in order to give that general shake-up to the torpid mind of the nation which the French Revolution gave to Continental Europe. England has never had any general break-up of old associations, and hence the extreme difficulty of getting any ideas into its stupid head. After all, what country in Europe can be compared with France in the adaptation of its social state to the benefit of the great mass of its people, freed as they are from any tyranny which comes home to the greater number, with justice easily accessible and the strongest inducements to personal prudence and forethought. And would this have been the case without the great changes in the state of property which, even supposing good intentions in the Government, could hardly have been produced by anything less than a revolution ?
I judge M. Guizot's conduct in the Spanish affair as you
[p. 132]1847
—
Aetat. 40.
do ; he is evidently not above low tricks and equivocations, which seem to be quite excused to every Frenchman by their being for the supposed honour and glory of France. Guizot I wished to think better of, but after all, this only brings me back, and that not altogether, to my first opinion of him, which some parts of his public conduct, from 1839 downwards, modified.
Your impression of Comte's delinquencies is a fine instance of the growth of rumour. Your informants must be either ill-informed, or such exaggerators that I wonder you should have believed them. In the first place, Comte (to whom I did not give money, but Grote and Molesworth did) never wrote to Grote anything but what was perfectly convenable. He wrote a letter to me which he authorised me to show to Grote and Molesworth if I thought fit, and I did think fit ; but it contained nothing like reproaches. It contained a theory that, in default of the Government, it is the duty of rich individuals to subscribe their money to enable philosophers to live and carry on their speculations. I do not agree in his theory. I thought it an instance of “the importance of a man to himself,” but even with the addition of his not having economised the money previously given to him this is a totally different thing from what you have been told.
The judgment to be passed on this incident would involve the wide subject of law ; the degree in which a person should be judged by his own deliberate principles should be combined with one's judgment on the principles themselves, and one's opinion of the causes which made him adopt them.
You ask what I think of the Irish measures. I expect nothing from them but mischief, or if any good, only through excess of evil. If you were here you would, I believe, think as I do. The Government and the public seem, both alike, to have parted company with experience and common sense. There is not one man in the House of Commons, and only two or three in the House of Lords (Whately being one) who seem to have a single sound or rational idea on the whole subject ; those from whom we
[p. 133]1847
—
Aetat. 41.
had most right to expect better are just as bad as the rest. I doubt if outdoor relief would do for Ireland under any mode of administration, but as it is, they are holding out to the people the most unbounded expectations, and if the Poor Law is to be worked without fulfilling them, the life of no guardian and no relieving officer will be worth a week's purchase, and the country will be ungovernable except by military occupation of every village. The only good I expect is that the result must produce a strong reaction in the public mind against the present wild notions about the mode of being good to the poor.—Ever sincerely yours,
J. S. Mill.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.





