To Dr. W. G. Ward, · touching on a variety of religious and other topics.
all your questions. I think you ought to allow me six volumes too…
To Dr. W. G. Ward,
touching on a variety of religious and other topics.
Spring of 1849.
1849
—
Aetat. 42.
Dear Sir,—You have given me six months to answer
all your questions. I think you ought to allow me six volumes too; for if the questions occupy so many pages, what must the answers? I could give no doubt some sort of replies to most of your queries in a few sentences, but they would not be such as could be satisfactory either to you or to myself. However, your letter is a sort of challenge which I am unwilling to refuse, though aware that
[p. 141]1849
—
Aetat. 42.
what I say will give scarcely the faintest idea of how much there is to say, and though I do not undertake to carry on the discussion any further. If I did, each answer would suggest further questions, and these would require longer answers, till I should be led into writing a treatise on each point—which, though if I live I may probably do, at any rate I had rather defer until I can do it thoroughly and in a shape for permanent use.
1st. Your explanations do not at all clear up, to my apprehension, what I think the inconsistency of blending high moral praise with the strongest language of moral reprobation. You say that certain states of mind are sinful in the greatest degree, yet that for those states the individual may possibly be not at all responsible. I can understand that persons may hold false and pernicious opinions conscientiously, and may have defects or peculiarities of character which, both in themselves and in their consequences, are extremely undesirable, yet to which their own wishes or voluntary conduct having in no way contributed, they are not morally accountable for them. But to call anything a sin and yet say that the sinner is not accountable for it, seems to me, if the word sin means anything, a direct contradiction. It is you who appear to be chargeable with what my opinions are usually charged with, viz., confounding the distinction between moral badness and mere aberration in a person or thing from the ideal perfection of the kind of being it belongs to. I recognise two kinds of imperfections: those which come independently of our will, and which our will could not prevent, and for these we are not accountable; and those which our will has either positively or negatively assisted in producing, and for which we are accountable. The former may be very hurtful to ourselves and offensive to others, but in us they are not morally culpable. The latter are. You ride over this (as it seems to me) perfectly definite distinction by the ambiguous word sin, under which a third class of defects of character finds entrance which is supposed to unite both attributes—to be culpable and ultra-culpable, although the person thus morally guilty
[p. 142]1849
—
Aetat. 42.
cannot help it. This seems to me to exemplify the unmeaningness of the word sin, which, if it is anything other than the theological synonym of “morally wrong,” is a name for something which I do not admit to exist.
2nd. On the subject out of which this discussion grew, population, marriage, &c., we differ so utterly that there seems not even a chance of our doing ourselves or each other any good by discussing it. Our ideas of moral obligation on the subject are completely incompatible ; the repugnancy goes down to the very root of the subject, and I entertain quite as uncomplimentary an opinion of your mode of regarding these questions as you can possibly do of mine. Two sentences will give some little notion of the wideness of our divergence. You think that the legality or illegality of an act makes a difference (not in its being right or wrong, socially speaking—but) in its purity or impurity, and you think that a man can, without forfeiting his title to respect, live in the habitual practice of that which he feels to be degrading to him. I, on the contrary, cannot conceive anything more gross and grovelling than the conception involved in the first supposition and the conduct described in the second. They appear to me the extreme of animalism and sensuality in the fullest sense of the bad meaning of those terms.
I will say no more on this subject except to correct a mistake you have made about my opinions on population. I do not know where you find that, on my showing, the evils of over-population are in some distant future. On the contrary, I hold with Malthus that they are, and have been throughout history, almost everywhere present, and often in great intensity.
3rd. You ask what are the natural instincts that civilisation has strikingly and memorably conquered. I answer, nearly all : e.g., the instinct of taking a thing we very much wish for, wherever we find it—food, for instance, when we are hungry. The instinct of knocking down a person who offends us, if we are the strongest. As a rather different example, take the eminently artificial virtue of cleanliness ; think what savages are, and what violence must be done to
[p. 143]1849
—
Aetat. 42.
the natural man to produce the feelings which civilised people have on this point; take again all the delicacies respecting bodily physicalities which savages have not a vestige of, but which, in the artificialised human being, often equal in intensity any human feelings, natural or artificial.
4th. As to the opinion I expressed in the “Logic,” that miracles are evidence of a revelation only to those who already believe in a God, or at least in supernatural beings; what I meant is this: we can never know that what is presented to us as a miracle is so. The proof can only be negative, viz., that we do not know any mode in which the thing can have been produced by natural means; and what is this worth when we are so ignorant of nature? Two years ago a man who, by passing a handkerchief across a person's face, could plunge him into a sort of ecstasy during which a limb could be cut off without pain, would have given apparent evidence of miraculous powers equal to any saint in the calendar. You ask, But what if the man himself, being morally trustworthy, affirms that it is a miracle? I answer, This would in many cases convince me that he himself believed it to be one; but that would weigh for absolutely nothing with me, as it is the easiest and commonest fact in the world, especially in an unscientific state of the human mind, that people should sincerely ascribe any peculiar and remarkable power in themselves to divine gift, and any unexpected prompting of their own minds to a divine communication. If the spectator did not previously believe in supernatural powers an apparent miracle will never give him, I conceive, any reason for believing in them, while he is aware that there are natural powers unknown to him; but if he does already believe in supernatural powers he has the choice between two agencies, both of which he feels assured really exist, and he therefore may and ought to consider which of the two is the most probable in the individual instance.
Next, as to Christianity. You need not have supposed any inclination in me to speak with irreverence of Jesus Christ. He is one of the very few historical characters for
[p. 144]1849
—
Aetat. 42
whom I have a real and high respect. But there is not, to me, the smallest proof of his having ever said that he worked miracles—nor, if he did, should I feel obliged either to believe the fact, or to disbelieve his veracity. Respecting St. Paul I have a very different feeling. I hold him to have been the first great corrupter of Christianity. He never saw Christ, never was under his personal influence, hardly even alludes to any of his deeds or sayings, seems to have kept aloof from all who had known him, and, in short, made up a religion which is Paulism, but not, me judice, Christianity. Even St. Paul, however, though I would by no means answer for his sincerity, never, that I know of, speaks of any particular miracle as having been wrought by him ; he only speaks, generally, of signs and wonders which may mean anything. The author of the Acts does speak of particular miracles, and those, like the miracles of the Gospel, I no more believe than I do the miraculous cures mentioned by Tacitus as wrought by Vespasian. I regard them simply as part of the halo which popular enthusiasm throws round its heroes. The argument of the “Horæ Paulinæ” scarcely aims at proving more than that St. Paul really wrote the epistles ascribed to him, which, in respect to all but one or two of them, no competent inquirer, I believe, seriously doubts (the case is very different from that of the Gospels), and that the Acts are, in part, an authentic record of St. Paul’s life, which I see no reason to disbelieve, any more than that Livy is in part a true history of Rome, and Herodotus of the countries of which he treats. Since I am on the subject I will add that I cannot conceive how, except from deep-rooted impressions of education, any reasonable person can attach value to any attestations of a miracle in an age when everybody was ready to believe miracles the moment they were attested, and even enemies, instead of denying the facts, ascribed them to diabolical agency. I would say to such a person, only read any book which gives a really living picture of, let us say, the Oriental mind of the present day. You there see hundreds of millions of people to whose habits of thought supernatural agency is of such everyday familiarity that if you tell them
[p. 145]1849
—
Aetat. 42.
any strange fact, and say it is miraculous, they believe you at once, but if you give them a physical explanation of it, they think you a juggler and an impostor. Add to this that until long after the time Christianity began you hardly find a trace, even in the best minds, of any regard for abstract veracity—any feeling which should prevent a teacher from deceiving the people for their good. Plato, the highest expression, probably, of the ethical philosophy of the ancient world, and the elevated nature of whose purposes it is impossible to doubt, thought it the duty of legislators to pretend a supernatural origin for their precepts, as all very early legislators seem to have done.
These are, I think, the more important topics of your letter. As to the condition of the labouring people as compared with former times, I incline to think them worse off as to quantity, though not quality, of food than three centuries ago, and better off as to clothing and lodging—but there is a sad dearth of facts that can be relied on. You speak of Macaulay and D'Israeli as authorities—anything that Macaulay says is not matter of observation, but of inference and argument, of which one must judge for oneself. As for D'Israeli and his Sybil, I cannot imagine its being received as testimony, or supposed to be anything but a commonplace story.
I am afraid I cannot be of any use to you in recommending treatises on astronomy, as it is many years since I read any of the more deeply mathematical sort. The most recent that I have read is that of Biot, which is probably by this time superseded. I have never read Laplace's “Mécanique Céleste,” but have understood that it is the most obscure, and by no means the best, of the treatises on the subject. Most probably Pontécoulant will answer your purpose. Nobody, I believe, ever hazarded a conjecture when the supposed condensation of the sun's atmosphere began, nor whether it is indefinitely progressive, or forms part of a cycle including periods of expansion as well as of contraction. I believe it is thought, though I know not on what grounds, that the throwing off of new planets has ceased. It is, I believe, mathematically demonstrable that
[p. 146]1849
—
Aetat. 42.
the supposed change could not alter the centre of gravity of the solar system, and therefore (as it cannot alter the total mass of matter) would make no difference in the orbits of the planets, or in any of the other effects of gravitation.
The opinion that all axioms are provided in the evidence of experience, rests, to my own mind, on the most complete proof ; but I always knew it would be very difficult to bring home that evidence to those trained in a different school of psychology from mine. Accordingly, I have failed to make you see (I do not mean admit) the main and characteristic points of my doctrine on the subject, viz., that our not being able to conceive a thing is no evidence of the thing being in itself impossible. You understand me correctly to say that the absence of any law of causation in some distant star, not only is, for anything we know, perfectly possible, but is even conceivable—but you ask, is it conceivable that in such a state two straight lines may inclose a space ? I say, certainly it is not conceivable, but that does not prove to me that the thing is impossible, since the limitation may be in our faculties, and in the allpervadingness, to us, of a contrary experience. Again, “the possibility of proving geometrical first principles by merely mental experimentation” seems to me to arise from previous experience, that in this particular department what is true of our mental images is true also of their originals, which I illustrated in the “Logic” by the case of a daguerreotype.
I agree with you that ratiocinative logic may usefully be taught separately from inductive, and belongs, indeed, to an earlier stage in mental instruction.
It is so long since I read Butler, and I have so little faith in opinions which we are not constantly revising, that I will not venture to express an opinion of him. I know that my father thought the argument of the “Analogy” conclusive against Deists, with whom alone Butler professes to argue, and I have heard my father say that it kept him for some time a believer in Christianity. I was not prepared by what I had heard from him for so
[p. 147]contemptuous an opinion as is indicated in some passages of the “Fragment,” though he never can have thought highly of Butler except by comparison with other writers of the same general tendency in opinion.
1849
—
Aetat. 43.
I am convinced that competent judges, who have sufficient experience of children, will not agree in the opinion you express, that they have a natural idea of right or duty. I am satisfied that all such ideas in children are the result of inculcation, and that were it not for inculcation they would not exist at all, except in a few persons of pre-eminent genius and feeling.
I have followed your example in expressing my meaning without polite circumlocutions, as I believe you really wish that I should, and any appearance of egotism or dogmatism in what I have said, you will, I hope, not attribute to my thinking my opinion important because it is mine, but will remember that what you asked me to do was to tell you, as a matter of fact, what my opinions are, and that, too, on subjects on which they are strong, and have been much and long considered.—I am, dear Sir, very truly yours,
J. S. Mill.
I should have answered your letter weeks ago had I not been out of town on account of health.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.







