To Edward Herford, Coroner of Manchester, · in reply to a letter from him, inviting Mill to join a society called the “Poor Law Reform Association.”
Sir,—I have to acknowledge your communication of January 9th…
To Edward Herford, Coroner of Manchester, in reply to a letter from him, inviting Mill to join a society called the “Poor Law Reform Association.”
January 1850.
Sir,—I have to acknowledge your communication of January 9th, inclosing a statement of the principles and objects of a proposed Association, which you do me the honour of wishing that I should join, and inviting me to communicate any observations which the paper suggests to me. In some of the objects of the address, and in some of the doctrines laid down in it, there is much that I agree with, but the question is, I think, more complicated than the writer seems to consider it. The present mode
1850
—
Aetat. 43.
1850
—
Aetat. 43.
of legal relief to the destitute was not adopted on any such absurd ground as that “it is better that the unemployed should be idle than usefully employed,” or better that the funds expended in supporting them should be consumed without a return than with a return. The “principle” acted on was, that by selecting employment for paupers with reference to its suitableness as a test for destitution, rather than to its productiveness, it was possible to make the conditions of relief sufficiently undesirable to prevent its acceptance by any who could find private employment. But if the State or the parish provides ordinary work, at ordinary wages, for all the unemployed, the work so provided cannot be made less desirable, and can scarcely be prevented from being more desirable than any other employment. It would therefore become necessary, either that the State should arbitrarily limit its operations (in which case no material advantage would arise from their having been commenced), or that it should be willing to take the whole productive industry of the country under the direction of its own officers.
You will perhaps say that these consequences could only arise if the work required in exchange for public pay were (as it usually has been) merely nominal; and that you rely, for preventing such a consummation, on the principle on which you justly lay so much stress, that of payment proportionate to the work done. It was tried, as I have understood, in the Irish Relief Works, and with the result which might be expected—viz., that if the rate of payment by the piece was sufficiently liberal not to overtask the feeble and unskilful, it enabled the strong and experienced workman to earn so much with perfect ease that all other employment was rapidly deserted for that held out by the public.
My own opinion is, that when productive employment can be claimed by every one from the public as a right, it can only be rendered undesirable by being made virtually slave labour; and I therefore deprecate the enforcement of such a right, until society is prepared to adopt the other side of the alternative, that of making the production
[p. 153]1850
—
Aetat. 43.
and distribution of wealth a public concern. I think it probable that to this, in some form (though I would not undertake to say in what), the world will come, but not without other great changes; certainly not in a society composed, like the present, of rich and poor, in which the direction of industry by a public authority would be only substituting a combination of rich men, armed with coercive power, for the competition of individual capitalists.
At present I expect very little from any plans which aim at improving even the economical state of the people by purely economical or political means. We have come, I think, to a period, when progress even of a political kind is coming to a halt, by reason of the low intellectual and moral state of all classes, and of the rich as much as of the poorer classes only. Great improvements in education (among the first of which I reckon dissevering it from bad religion) is the only thing to which I should look for permanent good. For example, the objects of your Association, and those of the promoters of emigration, even if they could be successful in putting an end to indigence, would do no more than put off to another generation the necessity of adopting a sounder morality on the subject of over-population, which sounder morality, even if it were not necessary to prevent the evils of poverty, would equally be requisite in order to put an end to the slavery to which the existing state of things condemns women; a greater object, in my estimation, both in itself and in its tendencies, than the mere physical existence either of women or men. I am sorry to see in your circular the ignorant and immoral doctrine that the separation enforced in the workhouse is among the sources of “degradation” and diminished “self-respect” for the pauper. I consider it an essential part of the moral training which, in many ways (but in none more important), the reception of public relief affords an opportunity of administering, and the improvement of which would be a reform in Poor Law management better worth aiming at, I think, than that which you propose.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.


