To the Editor of the Weekly Dispatch.
Sir,—I cannot remain quite silent on the unjust and unfounded attacks made by the…
To the Editor of the Weekly Dispatch.
This letter appears not to have been printed.
1st February 1851.
1851
—
Aetat. 44.
Sir,—I cannot remain quite silent on the unjust and unfounded attacks made by the Dispatch on those whom it calls by the old-fashioned appellation of sceptics. In the first article of the number for January 26th there is a charge against all who hold merely negative opinions on religion of being “Epicureans,” who “take the world as they find it”; of “believing in nothing,” being “earnest in nothing,” being “merely speculative, and inquisitive, logical thinking machines.” Whoever wrote these accusations, believing them to be true, is as ignorant of life and the world, and of the opinions of instructed persons in the present age, as a Church of England parson. I affirm that nearly all the persons I have known who were, and are, eminently distinguished by a passion for the good of mankind hold the opinions respecting religion which your article stigmatises; that is, they think that nothing can be known on the subject. The very phrase, “believing nothing,” as a synonym for believing no religious creed, as if nothing were true or false, right or wrong, except with reference to some theory of creation, is one of the calumnies of short-sighted and ignorant intolerance. But your writer, like other heretics, must have a scapegoat to whom to pass on the slanders thrown upon themselves, and be able to say to the bigots, “It is not I, it is my brother.” According to him, those who pull down one positive religion
[p. 158]1851
—
Aetat. 44.
, if it is to put up another, however slight and flimsy, are heroes; but if they see no sufficient evidence for any belief as to the origin and purpose of the world, and will not succumb to the vulgar by professing any, against them you indorse the accusations of the orthodox. The smallest ray of dogmatic religion is enough, in the opinion of its professors, to entitle them to call themselves infinitely higher and worthier than those who profess no dogmatic belief. But as all my own experience and observation lead me to an exactly opposite conclusion, I strenuously deny the accusation in the Dispatch, and charge the writer of it with bearing false witness against his neighbour.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

