To John Chapman, · on the first draft of the prospectus of the Westminster Review.
The prospectus says that the Review is to be “distinctly characterised by certain…
To John Chapman,
on the first draft of the prospectus of the Westminster Review.
9th June 1851.
Sir,—I have read the prospectus on which you ask my opinion, and I now put down some of the remarks which occur to me on the subject. The prospectus is addressed to “the friends of philosophic reform”; I think this a bad phrase. “Philosophic reformers” is a worn-out and gone-by expression; it had a meaning twenty years ago; “philosophic reform” does not, to my mind, carry any meaning at all unless to signify a reform in philosophy.
The prospectus says that the Review is to be “distinctly characterised by certain definite but broad principles”; but instead of laying down any such principles it contains little else than details of the measures which the Review will advocate on the principal political questions just now discussed in the newspapers. The only sentence which seems intended for a declaration of principles is that forming the third paragraph, and this, so far from “distinctly characterising” any set of opinions or course of conduct, contains nothing to distinguish the Review from any Liberal or semi-Liberal newspaper or periodical, or from anybody who says he is for reform but not for revolution. The doctrine stated, such as it is, I do not agree in. Instead of thinking that “strength and durability are the result only of a slow and peaceful development,” I think that changes effected rapidly and by force are often the only ones which in given circumstances would be permanent; and by the statement that “reforms, to be salutary, must be graduated to the average
[p. 163]1851
—
Aetat. 45.
moral and intellectual growth of society," I presume is meant (though I am by no means sure about the meaning, if any) that the measures of a Government ought never to be in advance of the average intellect and virtue of the people, according to which doctrine there would never have been the Reformation, the Commonwealth, or the Revolution of 1688; and the stupidity and habitual indifference of the mass of mankind would bear down by its dead weight all the efforts of the more intelligent and active-minded few.
The prospectus says "the Review will not neglect that important range of subjects which are related to politics as an inner concentric circle, and which have been included under the term sociology." I understand by sociology not a particular class of subjects included within politics, but a vast field including it—the whole field of inquiry and speculation respecting human society and its arrangements, of which the forms of government and the principles of the conduct of governments are but a part. And it seems to me impossible that even the politics of the day can be discussed on principle or with a view to anything but the exigencies of the moment unless by setting out from definite opinions respecting social questions more fundamental than what is commonly called politics. I cannot therefore understand how a review making the professions which the prospectus does, can treat such questions as a particular "range of subjects" which will merely not be neglected, and on which "diverse theories" will be considered with a view chiefly to ascertain "how far our efforts after a more perfect social state must be restrained" by certain conditions mentioned. I confess it seems to me the only worthy object of a review of progress is to consider how far and in what manner such objects may be promoted, and how the obstacles, whether arising from the cause mentioned or from any other, may most effectually be overcome.
In conclusion, I think it right to say that if your wish to consult me respecting the Westminster Review arises
[p. 164]1851
—
Aetat. 45.
from any belief that I am likely to be a contributor to it, I can hold out no prospect that the expectation will be realised. My willingness to contribute even occasionally to the Westminster under any new management would entirely depend on the opinion I form of it after seeing it in operation.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.


