To Thomas Carlyle.

J. S. MillThomas Carlyle

My dear Friend,—Many thanks for your little note.

17 · VII · 1832LondonPrinted pp. 32–36

To Thomas Carlyle.

My dear Friend,—Many thanks for your little note. I hope this letter will find all your perplexities at an end, and the paper on Goethe proceeding smoothly, or perhaps long since finished and sent off. I recognise in your account of what was passing in your mind, a very perfect picture of what I often experience in mine ; especially if I attempt to give a general view of any great subject, when I feel bound not merely to say something true, but to omit nothing which is material to the truth. I also participate in what you call your superstition about never turning back when one has begun. Were it not that imperfect and dim light is yet better than total darkness, there would be little encouragement to attempt enlightening either oneself or the world. But the real encouragement is, that he who does the best he can, always does some good, even when in his direct aim he totally fails. For although the task which we undertake is to speak a certain portion of precious Truth (and instead of speaking any Truth at all, it is possible our light may be nothing but a feu follet, and we may leave ourselves and others no wiser than we found them), still, that any one sincere mind, doing all it can to gain insight into a thing, and endeavouring to declare truthfully all it sees, declares this (be it what it may), is itself a truth ; no inconsiderable one ; which at least it depends upon ourselves to be fully assured of, and which is often not less, sometimes perhaps more, profitable to the hearer or reader, than much sounder doctrine delivered without intensity of conviction ; and this is one eternal and inestimable preeminence

[p. 33]

1832
—
Aetat. 26.

(even in the productions of pure intellect) which the doings of an honest heart possess over those of men of the strongest and most cultivated powers of mind when directed to any other end in preference to, or even in conjunction with, Truth. He who paints a thing as he actually saw it, though it were only by an optical illusion, teaches us, if nothing else, at least the nature of sight, and of spectra and phantasms; but if somebody has not seen, or even believed that he saw, anything at all, but has merely thrown together objects and colours at random or to gain some point, it is all false and hollow, and nobody is the wiser or better, or ever can be so, from what has been done, but may be greatly the more ignorant, more confused, and worse.

I have read your little paper on Goethe in Bulwer's Magazine. There was little in it which I had not already heard from your lips, otherwise there are passages which would, if they had been entirely new to me, have excited me to much thought, and may therefore do that service to any other mind which is prepared for them. I do not myself, as yet, sufficiently know Goethe, to feel certain that he is the great High Priest and Pontiff you describe him; I know him as yet only as one of the wisest men, and men of greatest genius, whom the world has yet produced; but if he be not all that you say he is, certainly no other man has arisen in our times who can even for a moment be suspected of being so. In him alone, of all the celebrated men of this and the last age, does a more familiar knowledge and the growth of our own faculties discover more and more to be admired and less and less to be rejected or even doubted of. Who shall succeed him; or when shall he find even an unworthy successor? There is need that the march of mind should raise up new spiritual notabilities; for it seems as though all the old ones with one accord were departing out of the world together. In a few days or weeks the world has lost the three greatest men in it in their several departments—Goethe, Bentham, and Cuvier; and during the same period what a mortality among those second-rate great men, who are generally in

[p. 34]

1832
—
Aetat. 26.

their own time much more celebrated than the first, because they take pains to be so; such men as Casimir Périer, or Mackintosh, or Sir William Grant, or General Lamarque, or the last of Scotch judges, John Clerk of Eldin, or even (to descend low indeed) Charles Butler, and here is Sir Walter Scott about to follow. I sometimes think that instead of mountains and valleys, the domain of intellect is about to become a dead flat, nothing greatly above the general level, nothing very far below it. It is curious that this particular time, in which there are fewer great intellects above ground and in their vigour than can be remembered for many ages back, should be the precise time at which everybody is cackling about the progress of intelligence and the spread of knowledge. I do believe that intelligence and knowledge are less valued just now, except for purposes of money-making, than at any other period since the Norman Conquest, or possibly since the invasion of the Romans. I mean, in our own country. But even in Germany the great men seem to have died out, though much of their spirit remains after them, and is, we will hope, permanently fixed in the national character.

I have not been idle since my last letter, but have rather read, than either meditated or written: all that I have written, you must have seen in the Examiner; it consists of sundry papers on French politics and two long articles on Pledges, which are in very bad odour with some of our Radicals. It is a proof of the honest and brave character of Fonblanque,1 that he wished to have these articles: everything he ever prints that does not chime in with commonplace Radicalism costs him money; his paper is in a perpetual alternation of slowly working its way upwards by its liveliness and ability and then tumbling plump down all at once by some act of honesty. I do not know that this has happened in the present case, but I have little doubt of it.

I am about to make a short ramble in the country just now, after which I shall return to work, and I hope with more solid and valuable results than I have hitherto

[p. 35]

1832
—
Aetat. 26.

done; so that I may produce something worthy of the title you give me, and in which I rejoice, that of one of your scholars. You also call me one of your teachers; but if I am this, it is as yet only in the sense in which a schoolmaster might speak of his teachers, meaning those who teach under him. I certainly could not now write, and perhaps shall never be able to write, anything from which any person can derive so much edification as I, and several others, have derived in particular from your paper on Johnson. My vocation, as far as I yet see, lies in a humbler sphere; I am rather fitted to be a logical expounder than an artist. You I look upon as an artist, and perhaps the only genuine one now living in this country: the highest destiny of all lies in that direction; for it is the artist alone in whose hands Truth becomes impressive and a living principle of action; yet it is something not inconsiderable (in an age in which the understanding is more cultivated and developed than any of the other faculties, and is the only faculty which men do not habitually distrust), if one could address them through the understanding, and ostensibly with little besides mere logical apparatus, yet in a spirit higher than was ever inspired by mere logic, and in such sort that their understandings shall at least have to be reconciled to those truths, which even then will not be felt until they shall have been breathed upon by the breath of the artist. For, as far as I have observed, the majority even of those who are capable of receiving Truth into their minds must have the logical side of it turned first towards them; then it must be quite turned round before them, that they may see it to be the same Truth in its poetic that it is in its metaphysical aspect. Now this is what I seem to myself qualified for, if for anything, or at least capable of qualifying myself for; and it is thus that I may be, and therefore ought to be, not useless as an auxiliary even to you, though I am sensible that I can never give back to you the value of what I receive from you.

I have no news worth telling you—scarcely any news of any kind. Mrs. Austin is quite recovered. Charles

[p. 36]

1832
—
Aetat. 26.

Buller is now in Cornwall; he was a little indisposed when he set out, but is now, I trust, in good health. Pray make my most friendly remembrances to Mrs. Carlyle, and let me hear from you in due season.—Yours ever faithfully,

J. S. Mill.

Notes

  1. 1[Albany Fonblanque, editor of the Examiner.]

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 86 of the 1910 edition (printed page 32), showing letter 9.
Printed page 32 · scan leaf 86 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 87 of the 1910 edition (printed page 33), showing letter 9.
Printed page 33 · scan leaf 87 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 88 of the 1910 edition (printed page 34), showing letter 9.
Printed page 34 · scan leaf 88 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 89 of the 1910 edition (printed page 35), showing letter 9.
Printed page 35 · scan leaf 89 of 378Open the full scan
Scan leaf 90 of the 1910 edition (printed page 36), showing letter 9.
Printed page 36 · scan leaf 90 of 378Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 9 of 165 · printed pp. 32–36 · scan leaf 86 of 378

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot, 1910, pp. 32–36.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationJ. S. Mill to Thomas Carlyle, 17 July 1832, “To Thomas Carlyle.”. In The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I, edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot (London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910), pp. 32–36. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/9/.

BibTeX@incollection{mill-letters-vol1-1910-letter-0009,
  author    = {J. S. Mill},
  title     = {To Thomas Carlyle., 17 July 1832},
  booktitle = {The Letters of John Stuart Mill, Vol. I},
  publisher = {London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910},
  year      = {1910},
  pages     = {32--36},
  note      = {Edited, with an Introduction, by Hugh S. R. Elliot. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/9/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/mill-letters-vol1-1910/9/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.