To C. E. Norton · [Carlyle; Ballads]
Your Emerson-Carlyle of course interested me very much, as I believe a large public also.
To C. E. Norton
[Carlyle; Ballads]
Woodbridge, May 12, '83.
My dear Norton,—
Your Emerson-Carlyle of course interested me very much, as I believe a large public also. I had most to learn of Emerson, and that all good: but Carlyle came out in somewhat of a new light to me also. Now we have him in his Jane's letters, as we had seen something of him before in the Reminiscences: but a yet more tragic story; so tragic that I know not if it ought not to have been withheld from the Public: assuredly it seems to me, ought to have been but half of the whole it now is. But I do not the less recognize Carlyle for more admirable than before—if for no other reason than his thus furnishing the world with weapons against himself which the World in general is glad to turn against him. . . .
And, by way of finishing what I have to say on Carlyle for the present, I will tell you that I had to go up to our huge, hideous, London a week ago, on disagreeable business: which Business, however, I got over in time for me to run to Chelsea before I returned home at Evening. I wanted to see the Statue on the Chelsea Embankment which I had not yet seen: and the old No. 5 of Cheyne Row, which I had not seen for five and twenty years. The Statue I thought very good, though looking somewhat small and ill set-off by its dingy surroundings. And No. 5 (now 24), which had cost her so much of her life, one may say, to make habitable for him, now all neglected, unswept, ungarnished, uninhabited
An illustration is printed here, on scan leaf 362.
I cannot get it out of my head, the tarnished Scene of the Tragedy (one must call it) there enacted.
Well, I was glad to get away from it, and the London of which it was a small part, and get down here to my
[p. 333]own dull home, and by no means sorry not to be a Genius at such a Cost. “Parlons d’autres choses.”
I got our Woodbridge Bookseller to enquire for your Mr. Child’s Ballad-book; but could only hear, and indeed be shown a specimen, of a large Quarto Edition, de luxe I believe, and would not meddle with that. I do not love any unwieldy Book, even a Dictionary; and I believe that I am contented enough with such Knowledge as I have of the old Ballads in many a handy Edition. Not but I admire Mr. Child for such an undertaking as his; but I think his Book will be more for Great Libraries, Public or Private, than for my scanty Shelves at my age of seventy-five. I have already given away to Friends all that I had of any rarity or value, especially if over octavo.
By the way there was one good observation, I think, in Mrs. Oliphant’s superficial, or hasty, History of English 18th Century Literature, viz., that when the Beatties, Blacks, and other recognized Poets of the Day were all writing in a “classical” way, and tried to persuade Burns to do the like, it was certain Old Ladies who wrote so many of the Ballads, which, many of them, have passed as ancient, “Sir Patrick Spence” for one, I think.
Our Spring flowers have been almost all spoilt by Winter weather, and the Trees before my window only just now beginning to
“Stand in a mist of Green,”
as Tennyson sings. Let us hope their Verdure, late arrayed, will last the longer. I continue pretty well, with occasional reminders from Bronchitis, who is my established Brownie.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.
![Scan leaf 362 of the 1919 edition (printed page 332), showing letter To C. E. Norton [Carlyle; Ballads].](https://archive.org/download/nineteenthcentur00reesrich/page/n361_w600.jpg)
![Scan leaf 363 of the 1919 edition (printed page 333), showing letter To C. E. Norton [Carlyle; Ballads].](https://archive.org/download/nineteenthcentur00reesrich/page/n362_w600.jpg)