To W. C. Macready · [“this is not the republic i came to see”]

Charles DickensW. C. Macready

I beg your pardon, but you were speaking of rash leaps at hasty conclusions.

22 · III · 1842BaltimorePrinted pp. 368–372

[Æt. 30

To W. C. Macready

[“this is not the republic i came to see”]

My dear Friend,—

I beg your pardon, but you were speaking of rash leaps at hasty conclusions. Are you quite sure you designed that remark for me? Have you not, in the hurry of correspondence, slipped a paragraph into my letter which belongs of right to somebody else? When did you ever find me leap at wrong conclusions? I pause for a reply.

Pray, sir, did you ever find me admiring Mr. ——? On the contrary, did you never hear of my protesting through good, better, and best report that he was not an open or a candid man, and would one day, beyond all doubt, displease you by not being so? I pause again for a reply.

Are you quite sure, Mr. Macready—and I address myself to you with the sternness of a man in the pit—are you quite sure, sir, that you do not view America through the pleasant mirage which often surrounds a thing that has been, but not a thing that is? Are you quite sure that when you were here you relished it as well as you do now when you look back upon it? The early spring birds, Mr. Macready, do sing in the groves that you were, very often, not over well pleased with many of the new country’s social aspects. Are the birds to be trusted? Again I pause for a reply.

[p. 369]

My dear Macready, I desire to be so honest and just to those who have so enthusiastically and earnestly welcomed me, that I burned the last letter I wrote to you—even to you to whom I would speak as to myself—rather than let it come with anything that might seem like an ill-considered word of disappointment. I preferred that you should think me neglectful (if you could imagine anything so wild) rather than I should do wrong in this respect. Still it is of no use. I am disappointed. This is not the republic I came to see; this is not the republic of my imagination. I infinitely prefer a liberal monarchy—even with its sickening accompaniments of court circulars—to such a government as this. The more I think of its use and strength, the poorer and more trifling in a thousand aspects it appears to my eyes. In everything of which it has made a boast—excepting its education of the people and its care for poor children—it sinks immeasurably below the level I had placed it upon; and England, even England, bad and faulty as the old land is, and miserable as millions of her people are, rises in the comparison.

You live here, Macready, as I have sometimes heard you imagining! You! Loving you with all my heart and soul, and knowing what your disposition really is, I would not condemn you to a year's residence on this side of the Atlantic for any money. Freedom of opinion! Where is it? I see a press more mean, and paltry, and silly, and disgraceful than any country I ever knew. If that is its standard, here it is. But I speak of Bancroft, and am advised to be silent on that subject, for he is “a black sheep—a Democrat.” I speak of Bryant, and am entreated to be more careful, for the same reason. I speak of international copyright, and am implored not to ruin myself outright. I speak of Miss Martineau, and all parties—Slave Upholders and Abolitionists, Whigs, Tyler Whigs, and Democrats, shower down upon me a perfect cataract of abuse. “But what has she done? Surely she praised America enough!” “Yes, but she told us of some of our faults, and Americans can't bear to be told of their faults. Don't split on that rock, Mr. Dickens, don't write about America; we are so very suspicious.”

[p. 370]

[Æt. 30

Freedom of opinion! Macready, if I had been born here and had written my books in this country, producing them with no stamp of approval from any other land, it is my solemn belief that I should have lived and died poor, unnoticed, and a “black sheep” to boot. I never was more convinced of anything than I am of that.

The people are affectionate, generous, open-hearted, hospitable, enthusiastic, good-humoured, polite to women, frank and candid to all strangers, anxious to oblige, far less prejudiced than they have been described to be, frequently polished and refined, very seldom rude or disagreeable. I have made a great many friends here, even in public conveyances, whom I have been truly sorry to part from. In the towns I have formed perfect attachments. I have seen none of that greediness and indecorousness on which travellers have laid so much emphasis. I have returned frankness with frankness; met questions not intended to be rude, with answers meant to be satisfactory; and have not spoken to one man, woman or child of any degree who has not grown positively affectionate before we parted. In the respects of not being left alone, and of being horribly disgusted by tobacco chewing and tobacco spittle, I have suffered considerably. The sight of slavery in Virginia, the hatred of British feeling upon the subject, and the miserable hints of the impotent indignation of the South, have pained me very much! on the last head, of course, I have felt nothing but a mingled pity and amusement; on the other, sheer distress. But however much I like the ingredients of this great dish, I cannot but come back to the point upon which I started, and say that the dish itself goes against the grain with me, and that I don’t like it.

You know that I am truly a Liberal. I believe I have as little pride as most men, and I am conscious of not the smallest annoyance from being “hail fellow well met” with everybody. I have not had greater pleasure in the company of any set of men among the thousands I have received than in that of the carmen of Hertford,* who presented themselves in a body in their blue frocks,

[p. 371]

among a crowd of well-dressed ladies and gentlemen, and bade me welcome through their spokesman. They had all read my books, and all perfectly understood them. It is not these things I have in my mind when I say that the man who comes to this country a Radical, and goes home again with his opinions unchanged, must be a Radical on reason, sympathy, and reflection, and one who has so well considered the subject that he has no chance of wavering.

We have been to Boston, Worcester, Hertford, New Haven, New York, Philadelphia, Baltimore, Washington, Fredericksburgh, Richmond, and back to Washington again. The premature heat of the weather (it was eighty yesterday in the shade) and Clay's advice—how you would like Clay!—have made us determine not to go to Charleston; but having got to Richmond, I think I should have turned back under any circumstances. We remain at Baltimore for two days, of which this is one; then we go to Harrisburgh. Then by the canal boat and the railroad over the Alleghany Mountains to Pittsburgh, then down the Ohio to Cincinnati, then to Louisville, and then to St. Louis. I have been invited to a public entertainment in every town I have entered, and have refused them; but I have excepted St. Louis as the farthest point of my travels. My friends there have passed some resolutions which Forster has, and will show you. From St. Louis we cross to Chicago, traversing immense prairies. Thence by the lakes and Detroit to Buffalo, and so to Niagara. A run into Canada follows of course, and then—let me write the blessed word in capitals—we turn towards HOME.

Kate has written to Mrs. Macready, and it is useless for me to thank you, my dearest friend, or her, for your care of our dear children, which is our constant theme of discourse. Forster has gladdened our hearts with his account of the triumph of “Acis and Galatea,” and I am anxiously looking for news of the tragedy. Forrest breakfasted with us at Richmond last Saturday—he was acting there, and I invited him—and he spoke very gratefully, and very like a man, of your kindness to him when he was in London.

David Colden is as good a fellow as ever lived; and

[p. 372]

I am deeply in love with his wife. Indeed we have received the greatest and most earnest and zealous kindness from the whole family, and quite love them all. Do you remember one Greenhow, whom you invited to pass some days with you at the hotel on the Kaatskill Mountains? He is translator to the State Office at Washington, has a very pretty wife, and a little girl of five years old. We dined with them, and had a very pleasant day. The President invited me to dinner, but I couldn't stay for it. I had a private audience, however, and we attended the public drawing-room besides.

Now, don't you rush at the quick conclusion that I have rushed at a quick conclusion. Pray, be upon your guard. If you can by any process estimate the extent of my affectionate regard for you, and the rush I shall make when I reach London to take you by your true right hand, I don't object. But let me entreat you to be very careful how you come down upon the sharpsighted individual who pens these words, which you seem to me to have done in what Willmott would call “one of Mr. Macready's rushes.”

I am ever, my dear Macready,
Your faithful Friend,

Charles Dickens.

Notes

  1. *Hartford, Connecticut.

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 398 of the 1919 edition (printed page 368), showing letter 244.
Printed page 368 · scan leaf 398 of 580Open the full scan
Scan leaf 399 of the 1919 edition (printed page 369), showing letter 244.
Printed page 369 · scan leaf 399 of 580Open the full scan
Scan leaf 400 of the 1919 edition (printed page 370), showing letter 244.
Printed page 370 · scan leaf 400 of 580Open the full scan
Scan leaf 401 of the 1919 edition (printed page 371), showing letter 244.
Printed page 371 · scan leaf 401 of 580Open the full scan
Scan leaf 402 of the 1919 edition (printed page 372), showing letter 244.
Printed page 372 · scan leaf 402 of 580Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 244 of 360 · printed pp. 368–372 · scan leaf 398 of 580

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
Nineteenth Century Letters, selected and Edited, with an Introduction (The Modern Student's Library), 1919, pp. 368–372.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationCharles Dickens to W. C. Macready, 22 March 1842, “To W. C. Macready · [“this is not the republic i came to see”]”. In Nineteenth Century Letters, selected and Edited, with an Introduction (The Modern Student's Library) (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1919), pp. 368–372. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/nineteenth-century-letters-1919/244/.

BibTeX@incollection{nineteenth-century-letters-1919-letter-0244,
  author    = {Charles Dickens},
  title     = {To W. C. Macready · [“this is not the republic i came to see”], 22 March 1842},
  booktitle = {Nineteenth Century Letters},
  publisher = {New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1919},
  year      = {1919},
  pages     = {368--372},
  note      = {Selected and Edited, with an Introduction (The Modern Student's Library). Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/nineteenth-century-letters-1919/244/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/nineteenth-century-letters-1919/244/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.