To George Smith · [“Henry Esmond”; Thackeray’s “cruel knife”]

C. BrontëGeorge Smith

It has been a great delight to me to read Mr. Thackeray’s work…

14 · II · 1852Printed pp. 417–418

[Æt. 35]

To George Smith
[“Henry Esmond”; Thackeray’s “cruel knife”]

My dear Sir,—

It has been a great delight to me to read Mr. Thackeray’s work; and I now so seldom express my sense of kindness that, for once, you must permit me, without rebuke, to thank you for a pleasure so rare and special. Yet I am not going to praise either Mr. Thackeray or his book. I have read, enjoyed, been interested, and, after all, feel full as much ire and sorrow as gratitude and admiration. And still one can never lay down a book of his without the last two feelings having their part, be the subject of treatment what it may. In the first half of the book what chiefly struck me was the wonderful manner in which the writer throws himself into the spirit and letters of the times of which he treats; the allusions, the illustrations, the style, all seem to me so masterly in their exact keeping, their harmonious consistency, their nice, natural truth, their pure exemption from exaggeration. No second-rate imitator can write in that way; no coarse scene-painter can charm us with an allusion so delicate and perfect. But what bitter satire, what relentless dissection of diseased subjects! Well, and this, too, is right, or would be right, if the savage surgeon did not seem so fiercely pleased with his work. Thackeray likes to dissect an ulcer or an aneurism; he has pleasure in putting his cruel knife or probe into quivering living flesh. Thackeray would not like all the world to be good; no great satirist would like society to be perfect.

As usual, he is unjust to women, quite unjust. There is hardly any punishment he does not deserve for making Lady Castlewood peep through a keyhole, listen at a door, and be jealous of a boy and a milkmaid. Many other things I noticed that, for my part, grieved and exasperated me as I read; but then, again, came passages so true, so deeply thought, so tenderly felt, one could not help forgiving and admiring. . . .

But I wish he could be told not to care much for dwelling

[p. 418]

on the political or religious intrigues of the times. Thackeray, in his heart, does not value political or religious intrigues of any age or date. He likes to show us human nature at home, as he himself daily sees it; his wonderful observant faculty likes to be in action. In him this faculty is a sort of captain and leader; and if ever any passage in his writings lacks interest, it is when this master-faculty is for a time thrust into a subordinate position. I think such is the case in the former half of the present volume. Towards the middle he throws off restraint, becomes himself, and is strong to the close. Everything now depends on the second and third volumes. If, in pith and interest, they fall short of the first, a true success cannot ensue. If the continuation be an improvement upon the commencement, if the stream gathers force as it rolls, Thackeray will triumph. Some people have been in the habit of terming him the second writer of the day; it just depends on himself whether or not these critics shall be justified in their award. He need not be the second. God made him second to no man. If I were he, I would show myself as I am, not as critics report me; at any rate I would do my best. Mr. Thackeray is easy and indolent, and seldom cares to do his best. Thank you once more; and believe me yours sincerely,

C. Brontë.

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 447 of the 1919 edition (printed page 417), showing letter 271.
Printed page 417 · scan leaf 447 of 580Open the full scan
Scan leaf 448 of the 1919 edition (printed page 418), showing letter 271.
Printed page 418 · scan leaf 448 of 580Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 271 of 360 · printed pp. 417–418 · scan leaf 447 of 580

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
Nineteenth Century Letters, selected and Edited, with an Introduction (The Modern Student's Library), 1919, pp. 417–418.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationC. Brontë to George Smith, 14 February 1852, “To George Smith · [“Henry Esmond”; Thackeray’s “cruel knife”]”. In Nineteenth Century Letters, selected and Edited, with an Introduction (The Modern Student's Library) (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1919), pp. 417–418. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/nineteenth-century-letters-1919/271/.

BibTeX@incollection{nineteenth-century-letters-1919-letter-0271,
  author    = {C. Brontë},
  title     = {To George Smith · [“Henry Esmond”; Thackeray’s “cruel knife”], 14 February 1852},
  booktitle = {Nineteenth Century Letters},
  publisher = {New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1919},
  year      = {1919},
  pages     = {417--418},
  note      = {Selected and Edited, with an Introduction (The Modern Student's Library). Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/nineteenth-century-letters-1919/271/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/nineteenth-century-letters-1919/271/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.