To Miss J—— H—— · [rejecting a novel]
The chief fault in your stories is the redundancy of words which overlays them…
To Miss J—— H——
[rejecting a novel]
193 Piccadilly, London, W., Nov. 22, 1864.
The chief fault in your stories is the redundancy of words which overlays them; and the chief hope visible in them is the copious youthful feeling running throughout. Your characters do not speak the language of nature, and this is specially to be charged against them when they are under strong excitement and should most do so. Nor are the characters very originally conceived, though there is good matter in the Old Welshman C. Rees. Your defect at present lies in your raw feeling. Time will cure this, if you will get the habit of looking resolutely at the thing you would pourtray, instead of exclaiming about it and repeating yourself without assisting the reader on in any degree. We* certainly think that you are a hopeful writer, and possibly we have been enough outspoken to encourage you to believe us sincere in saying so.
Notes
- *Meredith was for several years literary adviser to Chapman and Hall.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.
