To M. André Raffalovich · [Carlyle and his wife; Stevenson]
Your article on Th. Carlyle’s “Reminiscences” was prompted, I think…
To M. André Raffalovich
[Carlyle and his wife; Stevenson]
Box Hill, Dorking,
May 23, 1882.
My dear Sir,—
Your article on Th. Carlyle’s “Reminiscences” was prompted, I think, rather by enthusiasm for the lady who stands close and in contrast with him, than by an accurate knowledge of his works, nature, and teaching. Our people over here have been equally unjust, with less excuse. You speak of vanity, as a charge against him. He has little, though he certainly does not err on the side of modesty:—he knew his powers. The harsh judgment he passed on the greater number of his contemporaries came from a very accurate perception of them, as they were perused by the intense light of the man’s personal
[p. 484]sincereness. He was one who stood constantly in the presence of those “Eternal verities” of which he speaks. For the shallow men of mere literary aptitude he had perforce contempt. The spirit of the prophet was in him.—Between him and his wife the case is quite simple. She was a woman of peculiar conversational sprightliness, and such a woman longs for society. To him, bearing that fire of sincereness, as I have said, society was unendurable. All coming near him, except those who could bear the trial, were scorched, and he was as much hurt as they by the action rousing the flames in him. Moreover, like all truthful souls, he was an artist in his work. The efforts after verification of matters of fact, and to present things distinctly in language, were incessant; they cost him his health, swallowed up his leisure. Such a man could hardly be an agreeable husband for a woman of the liveliest vivacity. But that is not a reason for your passing condemnation on him. Study well his writings. I knew them both. She did me the honour to read my books, and make him listen to extracts, and he was good enough to repeat that “the writer thereof was no fool”—high praise from him. They snapped at one another, and yet the basis of affection was mutually firm. She admired, he respected, and each knew the other to be honest. Only she needed for her mate one who was more a citizen of the world, and a woman of the placid disposition of Milton’s Eve, framed by her master to be an honest labourer’s cook and housekeeper, with a nervous system resembling a dumpling, would have been enough for him.—He was the greatest of the Britons of his time—and after the British fashion of not coming near perfection; Titanic, not Olympian: a heaver of rocks, not a shaper. But if he did no perfect work, he had lightning’s power to strike out marvellous pictures and reach to the inmost of men with a phrase.
We had Mr. Louis Stevenson in our Valley, staying with his wife and father and mother at the inn. He dined with me several evenings, and talked of you. We speculated on the impression produced by his costume de Bohême, which he seems to have adopted for good—an innocent eccentricity at any rate.
My thanks are due to you for your articles on my works.
[p. 485]Pardon me if I do not correspond regularly. I am compelled to shun writing as much as possible, and scarcely hope to be of much in the world until I have gone through some course of water-cure for unstrung nerves. They tell me that good douches are to be had at Evian, and I rather decide to go thither at the end of July, thence perhaps to the Engadine or the South Tyrol Dolomites, if my ancient talent for walking should be restored. You, who have youth, take my warning not to undermine it with the pick and blasting powder of pen and ink.—I am, with warmest greetings to you, your most faithful and obliged,
George Meredith.
[Æt. 60
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.


