To Robert Louis Stevenson · [“Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde,” with a suggestion]
I doubt whether any one has the right so to scrutinise “the abysmal deeps of…
To Robert Louis Stevenson
[“Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde,” with a suggestion]
Davos, March 1, 1886.
I doubt whether any one has the right so to scrutinise “the abysmal deeps of personality.” You see I have been reading Dr. Jekyll. At least I think he ought to bring more of distinct belief in the resources of human nature, more faith, more sympathy with our frailty, into the matter than you have done. The art is burning and intense. The Peau de Chagrin disappears, and Poe's work is water. Also one discerns at once that this is an allegory of all two-natured souls who yield consciously to evil. Most of us are on the brink of educating a Mr. Hyde at some epoch of our being. But the scientific cast of the allegory will only act as an incentive to moral self-murder with those who perceive the allegory's profundity. Louis,
[p. 497]how had you the “ilia dura, ferro et ære triplici duriora,” to write Dr. Jekyll? I know now what was meant when you were called a sprite.
You see I am trembling under the magician’s wand of your fancy, and rebelling against it with the scorn of a soul that hates to be contaminated with the mere picture of victorious evil. Our only chance seems to me to be to maintain, against all appearances, that evil can never and in no way be victorious.
I would that you would tell me whether you only used your terrible motif as a good ground-work for a ghastly tale, or whether you meant it to have a moral purpose. But I suppose you won’t tell me.
I seem to have lost you so utterly that I can afford to fling truth of the crudest in your face. And yet I love you and think of you daily, and have Dew Smith’s portrait of you in front of me.
The suicide end of Dr. Jekyll is too commonplace. Dr. Jekyll ought to have given Mr. Hyde up to justice. This would have vindicated the sense of human dignity which is so horribly outraged in your book.
[Æt. 50]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

