Benjamin Clough to Asa Clough · [murder at sea]
A favorable chance having presented itself, I embrace it to write you a few lines.
Benjamin Clough to Asa Clough
[murder at sea]
On Board Ship Sharon, of Fairhaven.
At Sea, Thursday, Feb. 9, 1843.
A favorable chance having presented itself, I embrace it to write you a few lines. After my last at Brava, we shaped our course for St. Paul's Island where we arrived making a quick passage. We stopped here a few hours and I went ashore in the boat. We pulled into a small basin on the east side of the island, which is supposed to have been the crater of a burning mountain, having boiling springs on the beach where you can catch a fish and heave him over your head into the spring, where he will be cooked and salted in a few minutes, the water being salt. We saw a few hogs, but too far distant to be got at with ease. There is nothing grows on the island but Scurvy-grass. We saw the grave of the mate of the Aeronaut of New London (Mystic), who was killed near this island by a whale in 1837. We caught a few fish and went on board, pulling past a great number of Wright Whales. We then shaped our course for Copang, where we arrived Oct. 26, dropped anchor and lay three days, but finding nothing to be got but water. A few Dutch here, and a thing by the name of Fort, but not much more. Some Chinese and the rest Malays. The Chinese have a Temple here and the Malays a Mosque, which are of not much account. After we left here, we passed through the Straits of Timor Bunda Sea, Pitt's Passage, Lokisang Channel, and Gillot's Passage into the Pacific Ocean, seeing Sperm Whales once in the Straits, but got none, three of our boat steerers having missed. We then started for Pleasant Island on the Equator in Long. 167, 20 E., the place of our destination. I would here observe that Capt. Norris has been frequently beating the steward, Geo. Babcock, a mullato belonging at
[p. 536]Newport, R. I., in the most barbarous manner. On the 12th Dec. 1841 I heard the Steward say, “O Sir, you will kill me,” and the mate went down and the Capt. came on deck and ordered him put in the rigging whare he gave him 2 dozen with the double part of 18 yarn, cut him down, and ordered him to go to his duty again. About 7 p.m. the bell rang for the steward but he not coming the mate went forward and sung out for him, when one of the men sung out that he was not coming until he was used better. He was then brought out by force and 8 of the crew put in irons. 2 of them were then seized up and given 2 dozen a piece and the rest, promising to do better, were all sent to their duty again.
We then went back on our cruising ground and cruised the season, having very bad luck, the Captain beating the Steward as usual. We then started for Rotumah and April 7th let go Anchor. We lay here and took in wood and water and 9 of our men left. We shipped 2 White men, 4 Kanakas, 2 Rotumah men, 1 Ocean and 1 Hope Islander, the last two being left here by other ships. We then started for our ground again and at Hope Island got more Natives.
This season the Devil appears to have entered our Captain with double force. About the middle of June the Steward he burnt his foot to blister all over. I would add that after we left Rotumah he was turned out of the cabin and put in cook, he not being allowed to leave the ship. At the time he scalt his foot, he was reduced to almost a Skeleton. Sometimes his eyes swelled so that he could not see, and the blood and corruption running from all parts of his body, the skin hanging in great flakes on his foot. Some times he would make him mix Meal in a Kid and set it on deck and eat raw meal with the Hogs. The 4th of July he gave him 7 dozen on the back, one on the head and one on the feet, he being made what is called Spread Eagle, that is, he being tied by the rists so that his feet could not touch and his legs seized out taut each way. The rope used was hemp whale line. From the first of July to the first of September he beat him almost every day, using any weapon that came to hand and making him rub the plank when there was any bunches in them until his Knees were worn nearly to
[p. 537]the bone and his foot a mass of corruption. He then undertook to cure them but whenever he dressed them he would stamp on them and kick him in the face until the blood would stream from his mouth and nose and then make him stuff up his nose with Oakum.
On the 1 of September he came on deck in the morning, sung out for the Steward as usual, which was, where are you, you damned Nigger you, and set him to oiling a couple of brass guns that stood aft, when the Capt. was informed that he had some Meat the night before, which he had not. He then got his rope and gave him a terrible flogging acrost the back as he was bending over oiling the guns. At 7.30 we got breakfast. After breakfast he got some salve to put on his wounds, and gave a great many kicks as usual in the temples. He told him to go draw a tub of water in the waist. He got up to go and stumbled a number of times from the Mizzen mast to the waist. It was with great difficulty that he could draw a bucket of water, which the captain seeing, came with a rope and kept flogging him over the back. After he got the water drawn he told him to get some sand and go to scouring, which he started to do and stumbled from Starboard to Larboard side, where he fell. The Capt. began to beat him with the rope to make him get up. He tried a number of times by getting hold of things and kept stumbling until he came to the cheptree where he fell to rise no more, Capt. Norris beating him all the time and he saying Oh Capt.—I am dying. He was sewed up in a blanket with his bloody clothes on and at sunset hove overboard.
The Captain has often said he would kill him in defiance of everything, and when he was beating him he say he expected to go to Hell for him and the day he killed him he told him he need not be afraid of going to Hell as they would kick him out of that. So ends as cold-blooded a murder as was ever recorded, being about eight months taking his life.
One of our men that we shipped at Rotumah when we were at Pleasant Island got into a canoe to desert when he was discovered and ordered on deck. When he got there the Captain catched him by the collar and the man catched hold of his shirt, the man being drunk, when
[p. 538]the Captain sung out for help and he was tied hand and foot with spun yarn. He then choked him and kicked him in the face, and the man said if he ever got loose he would take his life. The Captain ordered him to be put into a canoe but we afterwards learned that he never reached the shore. This was before the Steward was killed.
Our Captain was also in the habit of pounding the Kanakas also. After the season was out we went to Ascension in Lat. 6.20 North, Long. 158.30 E. Whilst we lay there recruiting the Captain kept drunk. 12 men left us here, saying they would not sail with a Murderer.
Oct. 27, 1842, we left Ascension for New Zealand to get men, the Captain keeping drunk nearly all the time and beating the Kanakas, we having 6 of them on board and but 11 of the rest of us. Nov. 5 we raised sperm whales and lowered two boats, leaving the Captain, steward and 3 natives on board, the Captain about half drunk. We struck a whale and killed him and continued chasing the School when we saw the colors at the main-top-gallant head set at half mast. We then pulled for the ship, when the man who was at Mast head said that the natives had killed the Captain and got possession of the ship, haveing the Cutting Spades, Harpoons, Lances, Wood, Bone belaying Pins, Hammers, etc., to keep the boats off. We then told the Steward to cut the halliards and let the Sails run down to stop the Ship's headway. We then pulled up to the Ship. They threw an axe into the Boat, wood, etc., so that we could not come near the ship without the loss of lives, the Natives keeping watch of each Boat with long spades in their hands and one at the wheel, the Sun being about 3 minutes high. Soon as it begun to grow dark we pulled out ahead of the Ship and I took a Boat knife in my mouth to keep off the Sharks, there being plenty around. I got overboard and silently swam for the Ship, just keeping my head above water enough to breathe. I got hold of the Eye bolt in the rudder, got up onto it, and then into the Cabin window. As I came alongside one of the Natives was standing between the Night heads pounding on a tin pan. As soon as I got into the Cabin window I took off my clothes, they being wet, and to be in a better condition for fighting
[p. 539]. I then got 2 cutlasses and carried them into the Forward Cabin and set them up at the Stairs. I then got some powder and balls and Muskets and commenced loading them. I could hear the natives walking about decks, getting Weapons together to keep off the boats. I had got 2 of the Muskets loaded and the Powder into the third one, and stepped into the After Cabin to get Balls when I heard someone coming down. I stepped to the door when I saw one of the Natives had just got to the bottom of the stairs, knocking the Muskets down that I set up there. Being no light in the Cabin, he could not see me so well as I could him. I stepped out and got a Cutlass, made a thrust at him, but it being dark I did not hurt him very bad. He gave a shout, catched hold of me and I hold of him. I stepped back into the After Cabin, he following, both of us having hold of the Cutlass. I then threw him onto the Cabin floor, when he began to sing out for the other Natives and I to work at him with my fist and the edge of the Cutlass which sawed across the back of his neck. I then jumped up and started for the Stairs, but he jumped up and slashed manfully for a minute or two, but it being dark he could not see me nor I him, but he hit me 8 or 10 times. I then stepped to the foot of the Stairs in forward Cabin and looked up and saw one of the Natives with a long spade about half way down the Stairs ready to cut if he could see anybody. I then took up a Musket and shot him through the heart, the Spade coming down at the same time and cutting me on the thick part of my Arm above the elbow, cutting to the bone. I heard the Native in the After Cabin breathe heavily and heard from him no more. I steped back into the Cabin, the blood running from all parts of my body like a stuck dolphin, in the dark, the boats away and one Native on deck. Directly he came along with a spade in his hand, but seeing one Native dead and seeing the other he went forward before I could get a Musket. I then called the Boats on board and a light was struck, and the Native laying on the Transom in the After Cabin when the Mate took a Musket and put a ball through his heart. He was dragged on deck and both of them thrown overboard.
The Captain was found dead on the starboard side
[p. 540]abreast of the after part of the Main rigging, his head nearly severed from his body and mangled by the Hogs, pieces of scull laying on deck. I then had my wounds dressed, being about 15 in number, my body being all over blood, both Cabin floors being covered with blood and the Starboard side of the deck. The next morning the Captain was buried with the usual ceremonies and the other Native found stowed away between decks and put in Irons and the Ship headed for Sidney. There we arrived 22nd of Dec., 1842. We delivered our Native up to the American Consul. We left the 6th of Jan., the Mate Thomas H. Smith, taking command and I am second mate. My wounds got healed up about the time we went into Sidney. We have now about 500 Blls of Sperm Oil on board.
But how long we shall be out is more than I can say. I have enjoyed very good health since we left Sidney except my Right hand which is so that I can hardly hold a pen.
We have got a good crew on board and I am in hopes that we shall do something as we are on good ground. I have not time to write more as I am holding paper in my hand. Give my respects to all Enquiring friends, etc.
B. Clough.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.
![Scan leaf 565 of the 1919 edition (printed page 535), showing letter Benjamin Clough to Asa Clough [murder at sea].](https://archive.org/download/nineteenthcentur00reesrich/page/n564_w600.jpg)
![Scan leaf 566 of the 1919 edition (printed page 536), showing letter Benjamin Clough to Asa Clough [murder at sea].](https://archive.org/download/nineteenthcentur00reesrich/page/n565_w600.jpg)
![Scan leaf 567 of the 1919 edition (printed page 537), showing letter Benjamin Clough to Asa Clough [murder at sea].](https://archive.org/download/nineteenthcentur00reesrich/page/n566_w600.jpg)
![Scan leaf 568 of the 1919 edition (printed page 538), showing letter Benjamin Clough to Asa Clough [murder at sea].](https://archive.org/download/nineteenthcentur00reesrich/page/n567_w600.jpg)
![Scan leaf 569 of the 1919 edition (printed page 539), showing letter Benjamin Clough to Asa Clough [murder at sea].](https://archive.org/download/nineteenthcentur00reesrich/page/n568_w600.jpg)
![Scan leaf 570 of the 1919 edition (printed page 540), showing letter Benjamin Clough to Asa Clough [murder at sea].](https://archive.org/download/nineteenthcentur00reesrich/page/n569_w600.jpg)