CXCIX. To George Sand

Gustave FlaubertGeorge Sand

Dear master, I received your article yesterday…

Printed pp. 225–226

CXCIX. To George Sand

Dear master, I received your article yesterday, and I should answer it at length if I were not in the midst of preparations for my departure for Paris. I am going to try to finish up with Aissé.

The middle of your letter made me shed a tear, without converting me, of course. I was moved, that was all, without being persuaded.

I look vainly in your article for one word: “justice,” and all our ill comes from forgetting absolutely that first notion of morality, which to my way of thinking composes all morality. Humanitarianism, sentiment, the ideal, have played us sufficiently mean tricks for us to try righteousness and science.

If France does not pass in a short time to the crisis, I believe that she will be irrevocably lost. Free compulsory education will do nothing but augment the number of imbeciles. Renan has said that very well in the preface to his Questions contemporaines. What we need most of all, is a natural, that is to say, a legitimate aristocracy. No one can do anything without a head, and universal suffrage as it exists is more stupid than divine right. You will see remarkable things if

[p. 226]

they let it keep on! The masses, the numbers, are always idiotic. I have few convictions, but I have that one strongly. But the masses must be respected, however inept they may be, because they contain the germs of an incalculable fecundity. Give it liberty but not power.

I believe no more than you do in class distinction. Castes belong to archeology. But I believe that the poor hate the rich, and that the rich are afraid of the poor. It will be so forever. It is as useless to preach love to the one as to the other. The most important thing is to instruct the rich, who, on the whole, are the strongest. Enlighten the bourgeois first, for he knows nothing, absolutely nothing. The whole dream of democracy is to elevate the proletarian to the level of the imbecility of the bourgeois. The dream is partly accomplished. He reads the same papers and has the same passions.

The three degrees of education have shown within the last year what they can accomplish: (1) higher education made Prussia win; (2) secondary education, bourgeois, produced the men of the 4th of September; (3) primary education gave us the Commune. Its minister of public instruction was the great Vallès, who boasted that he scorned Homer!

In three years every Frenchman can know how to read. Do you think that we shall be the better off? Imagine on the other hand that in each commune, there was one bourgeois, only one, who had read Bastiat, and that this bourgeois was respected, things would change.

However I am not discouraged as you are, and the present government pleases me, because it has no principle, no metaphysics, no humbug. I express myself very badly. Moreover you deserve a different response, but I am much hurried.

I hear today that the mass of the Parisians regrets Badinguet. A plebiscite would declare for him, I do not doubt it, universal suffrage is such a fine thing.

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 269 of the 1922 edition (printed page 225), showing letter CXCIX.
Printed page 225 · scan leaf 269 of 432Open the full scan
Scan leaf 270 of the 1922 edition (printed page 226), showing letter CXCIX.
Printed page 226 · scan leaf 270 of 432Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter CXCIX of 321 · printed pp. 225–226 · scan leaf 269 of 432

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
The George Sand-Gustave Flaubert Letters, with an Introduction by Stuart P. Sherman, 1922, pp. 225–226.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationGustave Flaubert to George Sand, “CXCIX. To George Sand”. In The George Sand-Gustave Flaubert Letters, with an Introduction by Stuart P. Sherman (London: Duckworth & Co. (Boni and Liveright), 1922), pp. 225–226. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/sand-flaubert-letters-1922/200/.

BibTeX@incollection{sand-flaubert-letters-1922-letter-0200,
  author    = {Gustave Flaubert},
  title     = {CXCIX. To George Sand, undated},
  booktitle = {The George Sand-Gustave Flaubert Letters},
  publisher = {London: Duckworth & Co. (Boni and Liveright), 1922},
  year      = {1922},
  pages     = {225--226},
  note      = {With an Introduction by Stuart P. Sherman. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/sand-flaubert-letters-1922/200/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/sand-flaubert-letters-1922/200/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.