121. · To R. Pohl.
The past weeks have been so taken up by rehearsals, performances, and other business…
121.
To R. Pohl.
Düsseldorf, May 13, 1851.
The past weeks have been so taken up by rehearsals, performances, and other business, that I have hardly been able to give a thought to anything else. I owe you so many thanks for the instalment you sent me. I am more than ever convinced, on seeing the serious character of your work, that our united energies should produce something good. But I am not sure that we can build upon this beginning.1 The music to the introduction alone would take up a whole evening, and is therefore too long, much as the ideas contained in it appeal to me. The plan of dividing the oratorio into two parts, to be performed on different days, is one to which I cannot reconcile myself, nor do I think it advisable.
What is to be done ? We must, I think, reduce the material to the simplest outline, or select a few only of the important events in Luther’s life. The supernatural element should be sparingly introduced, for it does not seem to me to suit the
[p. 272]character of the Reformer at all. We know him to have been upright, manly, and self-reliant.
It is so difficult to explain this sort of thing by letter. Everything could be arranged in half the time if we lived together for a while, as I could wish.
I should be grieved indeed to hear that the difficulties had induced you to give up the work altogether. I was looking forward to making some progress with it this summer. Please let me know soon what you really think, and whether the difficulties in the way of carrying out the splendid idea that possesses us are to be surmounted.
Notes
- 1The first part of a trilogy on Luther which Pohl had planned out. Unfortunately, Schumann’s work was never written.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

