126. · To C. v. Bruyck.
I delayed answering your kind letter until I received Schön Hedwig…
126.
To C. v. Bruyck.1
Düsseldorf, May 8, 1853.
My very dear Sir,
I delayed answering your kind letter until I received Schön Hedwig,2 which has just arrived. I have much pleasure in enclosing it; will you please give the second copy to Dr. Hebbel, with my kind regards? The form of the composition is, I think, entirely novel. We so often have to
[p. 278]thank the poets for inspiration to seek out new paths in art.
Many thanks, too, for your last sympathetic letter. I should like you to hear my larger orchestral works ; for, although I may say I bestow the same care on my smaller works, the handling of a mass of material demands quite a different concentration of energy.
I was much interested in what you said about Wagner. He is, to put it concisely, not a good musician. He has no sense of form or euphony. You must not, however, judge by pianoforte arrangements of his scores. Many parts of his operas could not fail to stir you deeply if you heard them on the stage. If his genius does not send out rays of pure sunlight, it exercises at times a mysterious charm over the senses. Yet, I repeat, the music, considered apart from the setting, is inferior—often quite amateurish, meaningless and repugnant ; and it is a sign of decadence in art when such music is ranked with the masterpieces of German drama. But enough—the future will pronounce the verdict. . . .
Notes
- 1Carl Debrois von Bruyck (1828-1902), a composer and writer on music in Vienna. He also wrote on Schumann.
- 2Op. 106, a ballad by Hebbel, set by Schumann as a declamation with pianoforte accompaniment. [Tr.]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

