45. · To A. von Zuccalmaglio.
First let me tell you that a few days ago I handed Mr. Mendelssohn…
45.
To A. von Zuccalmaglio.2
Leipzig, January 31, 1837.
My very dear Sir,
First let me tell you that a few days ago I handed Mr. Mendelssohn, with whom I dine regularly, your essay, Erste Töne, to read. I watched from a distance to see how he would screw up his face when he came to that passage at the end, which, I confess, brought the tears to my eyes. He read it attentively, betraying, by the expression of his noble, unforgettable face, his increasing approval. Then came the particular passage. You should have seen him ! ‘Ah ! what’s this ? It is really too much ; this gives me real pleasure. One gets praised in all sorts of ways, but this comes straight from the heart,’ etc. You should have seen and heard him ! ‘Many, many
[p. 107]thanks to the writer !’ And so he went on; and then we plunged into champagne.
But really I have been saying to myself for a long time that no one has ever written about music like Wedel.1 Every turn of thought is so artistic, every cadence so musical. It is like reading in Mendelssohn’s face, which is so mobile as to reflect his own thoughts and his surroundings as well. But enough.
Do you know his Saint Paul, which is a chain of beautiful thoughts. He is actually the first to give the graces a place in church music, and they really should not be forgotten, although up till now the ubiquitous fugue has barred the way. Do read Saint Paul, and the sooner the better. In spite of what people say, there is no trace of Händel or Bach in it beyond what is common to all church music. If I could but see you and talk to you in the summer! I am sorry to say that you will probably not find Mendelssohn here, as he is to spend the summer with his fiancée in Frankfurt. His engagement makes a perfect child of him.
Have you any smaller poems, suitable for musical composition, for the paper ? I cannot help you with your tragedy. At the mere mention of the word ‘ tragedy,’ Barth2 looked me up and down. But if you will arrange your ‘ Wedeliana,’ I can, I hope, help you there. . . .
Notes
- 2Anton Wilhelm Florentin Zuccalmaglio (1803-1869), one of the best contributors to Schumann’s paper.
- 1Zuccalmaglio’s pen-name.
- 2The publisher, J. A. Barth.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

