80. · Robert to Clara.
Thalberg lives a long way from me. We have not met for a month…
80.
Robert to Clara.
December 3, 1838.
Thalberg1 lives a long way from me. We have not met for a month, but I shall see him this evening at Dessauer's. He leaves for Leipzig to-morrow on his way to Berlin and other places. He played beautifully at his concerts, but his compositions certainly lack vitality. I confess that to me, and to many others here, you are worth ten of him. My lame hand makes me wretched sometimes—here especially. It grows worse, too, as I don't mind admitting to you. I often bemoan my fate, and demand to know why Heaven should send me this particular trial. It would mean so much here if I were able to play. What a relief to give utterance to all the music surging within me! As it is, I can barely play at all, but stumble along with my fingers all mixed up in a terrible way. It causes me great distress.
Well, I have you for my right hand. Take care that nothing happens to you. I often think of the happy hours I shall spend listening to you. Are you still working as hard as ever? I know you are. The satisfaction which the knowledge of your own power affords you may be even keener when you have a constant listener able to appreciate
[p. 196]you and follow your every mood. Have you been writing and composing lately?
. . . Let me give you one piece of advice: don't improvise too much. It is such a waste of precious material. Make a point of writing everything down; you will thus collect and concentrate your ideas. You are denied the tranquillity and security from interruption which are the essential conditions for finishing a composition perfectly. But time may one day bring you these. . . .
I have composed very little here; I seem to have lost the art. But I have been through that stage before, and know that I shall work all the better after it. You may be sure that I shall not let Vienna spoil me.
Notes
- 1Sigismund Thalberg (1812-1871), Liszt's rival in the public favour as a pianist.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

