Benjamin Robert Haydon to Miss Mitford
You are unjust, depend upon it, in your estimate of Byron's poetry…
Benjamin Robert Haydon to Miss Mitford
[1824.]
You are unjust, depend upon it, in your estimate of Byron's poetry, and wrong in your ranking Wordsworth beyond him. There are things in Byron's poetry so exquisite, that fifty or five hundred years hence they will be read, felt, and adored throughout the world. I grant that Wordsworth is very pure and very holy, and very orthodox, and occasionally very elevated, highly poetical, and oftener insufferably obscure, starched, dowdy, anti-human and anti-sympathetic, but he will never be ranked above Byron nor classed with Milton, he will not, indeed. He wants the constructive power, the lucidus ordo of the greatest minds, which is as much a proof of the highest order as any other quality. I dislike his selfish Quakerism ; his affectation of superior virtue ; his utter insensibility to the frailties —the beautiful frailties of passion. I was once walking with him in Pall Mall ; we darted into Christie's.35 A copy of the Transfiguration was at the head of the room, and in the corner a beautiful copy of the Cupid and Psyche [statues] kissing. Cupid is taking her lovely chin, and turning her pouting mouth to
[p. 46]meet his while he archly bends his own down, as if saying, “Pretty dear!” You remember this exquisite group? . . . Catching sight of the Cupid, as he and I were coming out, Wordsworth’s face reddened, he showed his teeth, and then said in a loud voice, “The Dev-v-v-vils!” There’s a mind! Ought not this exquisite group to have roused his “Shapes of Beauty,” and have softened his heart as much as his old grey-mossed rocks, his withered thorn, and his dribbling mountain streams? I am altered about Wordsworth, very much, from finding him a bard too elevated to attend to the music of humanity. No, No! give me Byron, with all his spite, hatred, depravity, dandyism, vanity, frankness, passion, and idleness, to Wordsworth, with all his heartless communion with woods and grass.
When he came back from his tour, I breakfasted with him in Oxford Street. He read Laodamia36 to me, and very finely. He had altered, at the suggestion of his wife, Laodamia’s fate (but I cannot refer to it at this moment), because she had shown such weakness as to wish her husband’s stay. Mrs. Wordsworth held that Laodamia ought to be punished, and punished she was. I will refer to it. Here it is—
She whom a trance of passion thus removed,
As she departed, not without the crime
Of lovers, who, in reason’s spite have loved,
Was doomed to wander in a joyless clime
Apart from happy ghosts, that gather flowers
Of blissful quiet in Elysian bowers.
I have it in his own hand. This is different from the first edition. And as he repeated it with self-approbation of his own heroic feelings for banishing a
[p. 47]wife because she felt a pang at her husband going to hell again, his own wife sat crouched by the fire-place and chanted every line to the echo, apparently congratulating herself at being above the mortal frailty of loving her William.
You should make allowance for Byron's not liking Keats. He could not. Keats's poetry was an immortal stretch beyond the mortal intensity of his own. An intense egotism, as it were, was the leading exciter of Byron's genius. He could feel nothing for fauns or satyrs, or gods, or characters past, unless the association of them were excited by some positive natural scene where they had actually died, written, or fought. All his poetry was the result of a deep feeling roused by what passed before his eyes. Keats was a stretch beyond this. Byron could not enter into it any more than he could Shakespeare. He was too frank to conceal his thoughts. If he really admired Keats he would have said so (I am afraid I am as obscure here as Wordsworth). So, in his controversy with Bowles;37 Byron really thought Pope the greater poet. He pretended that a man who versified the actual vices or follies was a greater, and more moral poet than he who invented a plot, invented characters which by their action on each other produced a catastrophe from which a moral was inferred. This at once showed the reach of his genius.
Notes
- 35Christie's was, and is still, a famous London auction-room.
- 36Wordsworth's Laodamia, one of his few poems on classical subjects, was published in 1815.
- 37Samuel Lisle Bowles (1762–1850), a clergyman who had edited the works of Pope, carried on with Byron a prolonged controversy, in which Byron defended the character and poetry of his favorite English poet.
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.


