Letter 87

My difficulty is that when, in my environment…

s.s. “Rhyndam”Printed pp. 142–145

My difficulty is that when, in my environment, some intense feeling of pride or resentment concentrates its red light within a certain limited area, I lose my true perspective of life and the world, and it hurts deeply

[p. 143]

my nature. It is not true that I do not have any special love for my own country, but when it is in its normal state it does not obstruct outside reality; on the contrary, it offers a standpoint and helps me in my natural relationship with others. But when that standpoint itself becomes a barricade, then something in me asserts that my place is somewhere else.

I have not yet attained that spiritual altitude from which I can say, with perfect assurance, that such barricading is wrong, or even unnecessary; but some instinct in me says that there is a great deal of unreality in it, as there is in all passions that are generated through contraction of consciousness, through rejection of a great part of truth.

I remember your wondering why Christ gave no expression to His patriotism, which was so intense in the Jewish people. It was because the great truth of man, which He realized, through His love of God, would only be cramped and crushed within that enclosure. I have a great deal of the patriot and politician in me, and therefore I am frightened of them; and I have an inner struggle against submitting myself to their sway.

But I must not be misunderstood. There is such a thing as a moral standard of judgement. When India suffers from injustice, it is right that we should stand against it; and the responsibility is ours to right the wrong, not as Indians, but as human beings. There your position is higher than most of our countrymen's. You have accepted the cause of India for the sake of humanity. But I know that most of our people will accept your help as a matter of course and yet reject your lesson. You are fighting against that patriotism whereby the West has humiliated the East—the patriotism which is national egoism. This is a comparatively later growth in European history and a far greater cause of misery

[p. 144]

and injustice in the human world than the bloodthirsty ferocity, the nomadic savagery, in the primitive history of man. The Pathans came to India, and the Moghuls, and they perpetrated misdeeds in their heedlessness; but because they had no taint of patriotism they did not attack India at the very root of her life, keeping themselves superciliously aloof. Gradually they were growing one with us; and just as the Normans and Saxons combined into one people, our Muhammadan invaders would ultimately have lost their line of separateness and contributed to the richness and strength of Indian civilization.

We must remember that Hinduism is not the original Aryanism; in fact, a greater portion of it is non-Aryan. Another great mixture had been awaiting us, the mixture with the Muhammadans. I know that there were difficulties in its way. But the greatest of all difficulties was lacking—the idolatry of Geography. Just see what hideous crimes are being committed by British patriotism in Ireland! It is a python which refuses to disgorge this living creature which struggles to live its separate life. For patriotism is proud of its bulk, and in order to hold in a bond of unity the units that have their own distinct individualities it is ever ready to use means that are inhuman. Our own patriots would do just the same thing, if the occasion arose. When a minority of our population claimed its right of inter-caste marriage, the majority cruelly refused to allow it that freedom. It would not acknowledge a difference which was natural and real, but was willing to perpetrate a moral torture far more reprehensible than a physical one. Why? Because power lies in number and in extension. Power, whether in the patriotic or in any other form, is no lover of freedom. It talks of unity, but forgets that true unity is that of freedom. Uniformity is unity of bondage.

Suppose, in our Swaraj, the anti-Brahmin community

[p. 145]

refuses to join hands with us; suppose, for the sake of its self-respect and self-expression, it tries to keep an absolute independence—patriotism will try to coerce it into an unholy union. For patriotism has its passion of power; and power builds its castle upon arithmetic. I love India, but my India is an Idea and not a geographical expression. Therefore I am not a patriot—I shall ever seek my compatriots all over the world. You are one of them, and I am sure there are many others.

Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.

Scan leaf 150 of the 1928 edition (printed page 142), showing letter 87.
Printed page 142 · scan leaf 150 of 212Open the full scan
Scan leaf 151 of the 1928 edition (printed page 143), showing letter 87.
Printed page 143 · scan leaf 151 of 212Open the full scan
Scan leaf 152 of the 1928 edition (printed page 144), showing letter 87.
Printed page 144 · scan leaf 152 of 212Open the full scan
Scan leaf 153 of the 1928 edition (printed page 145), showing letter 87.
Printed page 145 · scan leaf 153 of 212Open the full scan

About this letter

Letter 87 of 115 · printed pp. 142–145 · scan leaf 150 of 212

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
Letters to a Friend, edited with Two Introductory Essays by C. F. Andrews, 1928, pp. 142–145.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationLetter, “Letter 87”. In Letters to a Friend, edited with Two Introductory Essays by C. F. Andrews (London: George Allen & Unwin Ltd., 1928), pp. 142–145. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/tagore-letters-to-a-friend-1928/87/.

BibTeX@incollection{tagore-letters-to-a-friend-1928-letter-0087,
  author    = {},
  title     = {Letter 87, undated},
  booktitle = {Letters to a Friend},
  publisher = {London: George Allen & Unwin Ltd., 1928},
  year      = {1928},
  pages     = {142--145},
  note      = {Edited with Two Introductory Essays by C. F. Andrews. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/tagore-letters-to-a-friend-1928/87/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/tagore-letters-to-a-friend-1928/87/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.