(8) · To The Same

Pramada Das Mitra

Dear Sir—It is more than a week since I received your letter…

7 · VIII · 1889Baranagore, CalcuttaPrinted pp. 7–9

(8)

To The Same

Dear Sir—It is more than a week since I received your letter, but being again attacked with fever at that time, I could not send a reply so long, for which please excuse me. For an interval of a month and a half I kept wel, but suffered again for the last ten days; now I am doing well. I have certain questions to put, and you, sir, have a wide knowledge of Sanskrit; so please favour me highly with answers to the following :

1. Does any narrative occur about Satyakâma, son of Jabâlâ, and Jânashruti, anywhere else in the Vedas excepting the Upanishads ?2

[p. 8]

2. In most cases where Shankaracharya quotes Smriti in his commentary on the Vedanta-Sutras, he cites the authority of the Mahabharata. But seeing that we find clear proofs about caste being based on qualification both in the Bhishma-parva of the Mahabharata and in the stories there of the Ajagara and of Uma and Maheshwara, has he made any mention in his writings of this fact?

3. The doctrine of caste in the Purushasukta of the Vedas does not make it hereditary—so what are those instances in the Vedas where caste has been made a matter of hereditary transmission?

4. The Acharya could not adduce any proof from the Vedas to the effect that a Shudra should not study the Vedas. He only quotes “यज्ञेऽनवक्लृप्त”1 to maintain that when he is not entitled to perform Yajnas, he has neither any right to study the Upanishads and the like. But the same Acharya contends with reference to अथातो ब्रह्मजिज्ञासा2 that the अथ here does not mean “subsequent to the study of the Vedas,” because it is contrary to proof that the study of the Upanishad is not permissible without the previous study of the Vedic Mantras and Brâhmanas and because there is no intrinsic sequence between the Vedic Karmakânda and Vedic Jnânakânda. It is evident, therefore, that one may attain to the knowledge of Brahman without having studied the ceremonial parts of the Vedas. So if there is no sequence between the sacrificial practices and Jnana, why does the Acharya contradict his own statement when it is a case of the Shudras, by inserting the clause “by force of the same logic”? Why should the Shudra not study the Upanishad?

[p. 9]

I mail you, sir, a book named “Imitation of Christ” written by a Christian Sannyasin. It is a wonderful book. One is astonished to find such renunciation, Vairâgya and Dâsyabhakti having existed even among the Christians. Probably you may have read this book before; if not, it will give me the greatest pleasure if you kindly read it.— Yours etc., Vivekananda.

Notes

  1. 2The real import of this question lies in the fact that Shankaracharya in his commentary on the Vedanta-Sutras, I. iii. 3-37, interprets the aphorisms to prove that Upanishadic wisdom was imparted to Jânashruti and Satyakâma, only because they were not Shudras, as borne out by actual texts. But as these texts are doubtful even after Shankaracharya’s explanation, Swamiji wants to be referred to other Vedic texts where mention has been made of these persons.
  2. 1“The Shudra is not conceived of as a performer of [Ya]jna or Vedic sacrifices.”—Taittiriya Samhitâ, VII. i. 1. 6.
  3. 2“This is the first aphorism in the Vedanta-Sutras of Vasa, It means. ‘Now then commences hence the enquiry about Brahman.’”

No public scan of this edition is linked yet, so the printed page cannot be shown beside the text.

About this letter

Letter (8) of 320 · printed pp. 7–9 · scan leaf 22 of 522

Where it sits in the book: black are letters, grey the editor’s narrative, pale the front matter, appendices and index.

Source
Letters of Swami Vivekananda, fourth Edition, 1944, pp. 7–9.
How it was read
Read by machine. Not yet proofread by people. Expect occasional slips in names, accents and foreign words. The book’s reading score is 100 out of 100. How this text was read
Take the whole book with you
EPUBMarkdownTEI
Cite this letter

CitationLetter to Pramada Das Mitra, 7 August 1889, “(8) · To The Same”. In Letters of Swami Vivekananda, fourth Edition (Mayavati, Almora, Himalayas: Advaita Ashrama, 1944), pp. 7–9. Paper Lanterns edition, https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/vivekananda-letters-1944/8/.

BibTeX@incollection{vivekananda-letters-1944-letter-0008,
  author    = {},
  title     = {(8) · To The Same, 7 August 1889},
  booktitle = {Letters of Swami Vivekananda},
  publisher = {Mayavati, Almora, Himalayas: Advaita Ashrama, 1944},
  year      = {1944},
  pages     = {7--9},
  note      = {Fourth Edition. Paper Lanterns edition},
  url       = {https://paperlanterns.ink/collections/vivekananda-letters-1944/8/}
}

Linkhttps://paperlanterns.ink/collections/vivekananda-letters-1944/8/

The link is permanent and will always lead to this letter.