LXIII · THE CHEVALIER DE LA BARRE · To M. d'Alembert
LXIII
LXIII
THE CHEVALIER DE LA BARRE
To M. d'Alembert
[On October 1, 1765, the young Chevalier de la Barre had been arrested on a charge of mutilating crucifixes, insulting a religious procession, and “uttering blasphemies” in Abbeville. On February 28, 1766, he, d’Etallonde (a friend, who had escaped to Prussia), and Moisnel, a boy of eighteen, were condemned to death, after having their tongues cut out and their hands cut off. Ten of the best avocats in Paris (the “ten humane and upright judges” of this letter) declared the brutal sentence illegal. A public appeal against it was made to the King. The case was re-tried at Paris, and the sentence confirmed. On July 1, 1766, la Barre (he was scarcely twenty) died “with the firmness of Socrates,” after having been put to the torture. With his body was burnt, with other contraband works, the first volume of The Philosophical Dictionary of Voltaire—who, with many others, had believed up to the last in a reprieve. As it was considered that the works of the philosophers—and of the Philosopher-in-Chief, chiefly—had been largely responsible for la Barre’s folly, Voltaire went for safety to Rolle, in Vaud.
[p. 200]There he wrote his noble tract in the cause of humanity, The Death of the Chevalier de la Barre, which, as he hoped, “frightened the carnivorous beasts off others,” not only saved Moisnel from a punishment so barbarously disproportionate to the crime, but forced the judges to drop the case altogether. He also obtained King Frederick’s protection for d’Étallonde: and in 1775, when d’Étallonde was at Ferney, pleaded for the restitution of his civil rights in a pamphlet entitled The Cry of Innocent Blood (see also Letter LXVIII, “The Case of Martin”).
“A lieutenant-general gagged”—General Lally (see Letter LXXXIV, “The Last Letter”).
“Five young men condemned to be burnt for follies which deserved Saint-Lazare.” There were really only three, d’Étallonde, Moisnel, and the Chevalier de la Barre: Voltaire was as yet imperfectly acquainted with the details of the case. Saint Lazare was the house of correction for juvenile offenders.
“The Preface of the King of Prussia.” This was a Preface to a volume entitled Extracts from Bayle’s Dictionary which had appeared in Berlin in 1766. The King turned the Preface into a panegyric of the proscribed and free-thinking Bayle (see Letter XII, “On the Liberty of the Press: and on Theatres”).
[p. 201]"The theologian Vernet" was a Calvinistic pastor of Geneva, with whom Voltaire had quarrelled on the vexed subject of play-acting. Vernet made the mistake of attacking Voltaire in print. Voltaire replied in a Dialogue between a Priest and a Protestant Minister, which caused Vernet "to complain to the Council of Geneva that he was being held up to ridicule." To this complaint Voltaire—just two months before this letter was written—had made answer in one of the most stinging personal satires that ever fell from even his pen and was entitled The Praise of Hypocrisy.]
Choose any passage to light it on the printed page.


